Go to content

DENNIS, James - Montgomery InGenWeb Project

Skip menu
Skip menu

DENNIS, James

Source: Crawfordsville Weekly Journal 3 Dec 1897 p 9

New Richmond Enterprise: “I’m Pearl Dennis, Mr. Bowles.  Won’t you save papa?” asked a little flaxen haired tot 12 years ago when she met Tom Bowles on the train as he returned from Indianapolis during the memorable incarceration of James Dennis as an accomplice in the McMullin murder.  Mr. Bowles then took the little girl in his arms and promised that he would invoke the aid of Heaven and earth.  A few days ago Mr. Bowles was accosted by a young lady who said, “Mr. Bowles, I’m Pearl Dennis,” and in telling of the incident to a Yelper pencil pusher he remarked that she was so pretty that he was again tempted to take her in his arms.  The little flaxen haired girl had developed into a handsome and accomplished young lady who will soon graduate from the Crawfordsville HS.  Her mother is in Attica receiving $5 per week in a laundry.  Her father, James Dennis died two years ago in Kentucky.  Mr. Bowles stayed all night with Dr. Detchon last week and rehearsed the incidents of 12 years ago.  He is in the lecture field at present.   - kbz



Source: Greencastle Times 14 May 1885 p 2

The wife of James Dennis who has been found guilty of the murder of the McMullens near Elmdale, Montgomery County has been returned from the Insane asylum and is at her mother’s.  She knew nothing of her husband’s trial until she was told by her mother.  Argument is being heard for a new trial for Dennis.   - kbz



Source: Franklin Evening Star 31 July 1885 p 1

Indianapolis July 30 – An appeal to the supreme court has been taken in the case of James Dennis, the murderer, sentenced to be hanged on Sept 3 at Crawfordsville.  An alleged confession completely exonerating Dennis made by John W. Coffee who was convicted and sentenced to be hanged for the same murder is the reason for the appeal   - kbz



Source: Indianapolis Journal 4 Nov 1885 p 2

Crawfordsville Nov 3 – This morning Prosecutor Anderson received a nolle prosequi in the case of James Dennis.  Judge Snyder then ordered the release of Dennis.  Just after dinner Dennis was set at liberty.  He went at once to the office of Doty & Thornton where his wife and children were, also his brother and Mr. and Mrs. Rankin.  The meeting between them was a joyous one.  Dennis was very cool and had not much to say. The entire crowd left for Elmdale about 4 o’clock.   - kbz



Source: Indianapolis News 17 Aug 1885 p 4

The Governor has reprieved James Dennis, one of the Crawfordsville murderers until Oct 16 to give the Supreme Court opportunity to pass upon the appeal and John W. Coffee also under death sentence and the chief witness against him will in all probability be similarly respited.   - kbz

Back to content