| Last Name | First Name | Elected Date | Succeeds Last Name | Succeeds First Name |
| Abery | Chancey | 1911 | ||
| Avery | Chauncey | 1908 | ||
| Bair | Royal | 1908 | ||
| Baker | Nathaniel | 1911 | ||
| Balch | William L. | 1898 | Balch | William L. |
| Ball | Newton | 1898 | Goff | B. J. |
| Bassett | James | 1890 | Hall | Charles E. |
| Batch | William | 1890 | Batch | William |
| Batch | William L. | 1894 | Vacant | |
| Bevington | John | 1890 | Bevington | John |
| Black | John G. | 1890 | Vacant | |
| Brouse | Orin L. | 1894 | Vacant | |
| Burch | Chester | 1898 | Vacant | |
| Burket | Lafayette | 1894 | Vacant | |
| Butler | Joseph | 1890 | Crandall | John |
| Cary | Nelson E. | 1911 | ||
| Cary | Nelson E. | 1908 | ||
| Clark | Mark R. | 1890 | Clark | Mark R. |
| Cobert | John | 1911 | ||
| Cobert | John | 1898 | Vacant | |
| Cook | Charles | 1890 | Terry | Thompson C. |
| Corbin | A. J. | 1894 | Corbin | A. J. |
| Corbin | A. Judson | 1890 | Corbin | A. Judson |
| Covell | William | 1898 | Letts | Nelson J. |
| Dick | Ervin | 1908 | ||
| Dick | Ervin V. | 1911 | ||
| Duher | Frank | 1898 | Vacant | |
| Ellis | W. W. | 1890 | Vacant | |
| Fast | Fred | 1911 | ||
| Fast | Fred | 1908 | ||
| Frederick | Michael | 1898 | Vacant | |
| Gillmore | Otis M. | 1898 | Gillmore | Otis M. |
| Gilmore | Otis M. | 1894 | Vacant | |
| Gleason | Charles E. | 1911 | ||
| Goff | B. J. | 1890 | Howell | James K. |
| Goff | Bethuel J. | 1894 | Goff | Bethuel J. |
| Goodale | John W. | 1890 | Goodale | John W. |
| Goodale | John W. | 1894 | Goodale | John W. |
| Goodale | John W. | 1898 | Goodale | John W. |
| Green | W. H. | 1898 | Vacant | |
| Griggs | Daniel | 1898 | Griggs | Daniel |
| Griggs | David S. | 1894 | Vacant | |
| Gundrum | T. E. | 1898 | Vacant | |
| Harpman | James | 1908 | ||
| Harpman Jr. | John | 1890 | Harpham Jr | John |
| Headley | Edgar L. | 1898 | Ingalls | Charles A. |
| Hughes | David S. | 1890 | Hughes | David S. |
| Ingalls | Charles A. | 1894 | Vacant | |
| Johnson | Jesse | 1898 | Morrow | John K. |
| Kelley | Francis M. | 1911 | ||
| Kelley | Francis M. | 1894 | Vacant | |
| Kelly | Francis M. | 1898 | Kelly | Francis M. |
| Kemery | Israel | 1894 | Vacant | |
| Kemery | Israel | 1898 | Kemery | Israel |
| Kile | James | 1911 | ||
| Kiles | James | 1908 | ||
| King | George W. | 1894 | Vacant | |
| Lemmon | William | 1894 | Vacant | |
| Letts | Nelson J. | 1890 | Young | Sidney |
| Light | Andrew J. | 1890 | Harmon | L. D. |
| Mallory | Martin | 1894 | Vacant | |
| McLouth | Benj M. | 1911 | ||
| Morley | A. | 1890 | Metzler | Jacob F. |
| Morse | Orin | 1898 | Vacant | |
| Morse | Orrin | 1908 | Neutz | George W. |
| Myres | George W. | 1894 | Light | A. J. |
| Osterhout | Samuel E. | 1908 | Morrison | John W. |
| Ousterhout | Samuel E. | 1898 | Philo | Ward |
| Parsell | Aaron G. | 1894 | Vacant | |
| Parsell | Aaron G. | 1898 | Parsell | Aaron G. |
| Phillips | John | 1898 | Vacant | |
| Phillips | Josiah | 1890 | Young | L. I. C. |
| Porter | Samuel D. | 1894 | Vacant | |
| Powers | George W. | 1890 | Powers | George W. |
| Pray | Daniel | 1890 | Wright | Monroe F. |
| Ramsay | Francis H. | 1911 | ||
| Ramsay | Francis H. | 1908 | Ramsay | Francis H. |
| Raub | John B. | 1890 | Bodley | Levi |
| Resler | George W. | 1894 | Vacant | |
| Rhoades | Richard F. | 1898 | Rhoades | Richard F. |
| Rhoads | Richard | 1894 | Vacant | |
| Rogers | William H. | 1908 | ||
| Rowley | Frank B. | 1908 | Thompson | Milo |
| Rummel | Jacob | 1890 | Rummel | Jacob |
| Sharp | Clyde F. | 1894 | Vacant | |
| Shutts | Joel G. | 1890 | Shutts | Joel G. |
| Shutts | Joel G. | 1898 | Vacant | |
| Simmons | Carie O. | 1894 | Vacant | |
| Smith | George S. | 1890 | Smith | George A. |
| Snowberger | Robert H. | 1908 | ||
| Souder | Isaac | 1894 | Vacant | |
| Sowle | Tracy | 1890 | Vacant | |
| Squire | William W. | 1890 | Squire | William W. |
| Straw | William R. | 1894 | Smith | George A. |
| Sturgis | Charles | 1908 | Coss | John F. |
| Swift | David K. | 1898 | Vacant | |
| Tasker | Thomas | 1898 | Young | Burton |
| Teeters | Alonzo | 1890 | Teeters | Alonzo |
| Thomas | Hezakiah | 1890 | Thomas | Hezakiak |
| Thomas | J. Wesley | 1898 | Thomas | J. Wesley |
| Thompson | Alexander | 1908 | ||
| Thompson | Milo | 1894 | Thompson | Milo |
| Turley | James | 1894 | Vacant | |
| Turley | James | 1898 | Turley | James |
| Watkins | Homer | 1890 | Haughey | Timothy |
| Wickman | Augustus C. | 1894 | Vacant | |
| Wigent | Freeburn A. | 1911 | ||
| Wren | James J. | 1894 | Vacant | |
| Wren | James J. | 1898 | Wren | James J. |
| Young | Burton | 1894 | Bassett | J. W. |