Bethlehem Cemetery
(aka Rachel Williams Pfister Memorial)

Located in Robb Township
South of the interstection of Byes Road (CR 500E) &  SR 68
(38.156263, -87.820820)


Last update:   

Surname
Given Name
Birth Date
Death Date
Notes
Veteran
Photo
Ackman
Lucretia
30 Apr 1821
20 Apr 1892
nee Pitcher.  Wife of William Ackman.  Married 4 Aug 1839 in Boone Co., Kentucky.  Married by S. Lynn.  Bond by Michael Snider.  Consent by mother:  Frances Pitcher.
Record of burial from C. Cox book.
Photo pending.
Ackman
Rufus
abt 1861
Sep 1938
Son of William & Lucretia (Pitcher) Ackman.

Aged:  77 y. 2 m.

Record of burial from C. Cox book.
Ackman
Sarah E
2 Feb 1844
27 Apr 1881
Daughter of William & Lucretia (Pitcher) Ackman.

Record of burial from C. Cox book.
Photo pending.
Ackman
William
28 Nov 1813
18 Jun 1887
Husband of Lucretia (Pitcher) Ackman.  Married 4 Aug 1839 in Boone Co., Kentucky.  Married by S. Lynn.  Bond by Michael Snider.

Record of burial from C. Cox book.
Photo pending..
Amick Nancy Alice 9 Dec 1860 18 Feb 1928 nee Nash. Wife of Lafe Cartwright, 1st, married 20 Feb 1881; third wife of John William Amick, 2nd, married 29 Oct 1887; and 3rd wife of Elisha W Stallings, 3rd, married 9 Dec 1909.

Daughter of John Clement & Hannah (Reeves) Nash.
   
Amick John William 24 Apr 1846 15 Nov 1907 Husband of Margaret "Maggie" (Clapp) Amick, 1st, married 28 Sep 1865 in Clark County, Indiana; Rosa Amanda Amick, 2nd, married 1876, probably in Clark County, Indiana;  and Nancy Alice (Nash) Amick, 3rd, married 29 Oct 1887 in Posey County, Indiana.

Son of Levi & Sarah (Overman) Amick.
 
Axton Enoch W 19 Dec 1867 4 Sep 1908 Husband of Fanniel A (Williams) Axton.  Married 26 Feb 1889.

Son of Thomas & Ellen Stallings.
   
Axton Fannie A 31 Mar 1871 18 May 1919 nee Williams.  Wife of Enoch W Axton.  Married 26 Feb 1889.

Daughter of Jerry & Alice (DeFur) Axton .
 
Britton
Elizabeth
abt 1812
1886
nee DeFur.  Wife of Hassell Britton.  Married 28 Mar 1833.


Britton
Eliza Ella
abt 1857
-
Daughter of Hassel & Elizabeth (DeFur) Britton

Britton
Francis M
abt 1847
-
Son of Hassel & Elizabeth (DeFur) Britton.

Britton
Hassel /
Hazel
abt 1808
23 Jun 1878
Husband of Elizabeth (DeFur) Britton.  Married 28 Mar 1833.

Son of William & Anne Stuart (Stewart) Britton.

Britton
James S
abt 1857

Son of Hassel & Elizabeth (DeFur) Britton.

Britton
Martha J
abt 1838

Daughter of Hassel & Elizabeth (DeFur) Britton


Britton
Permelia "Pam"
abt 1841
-
Daughter of Hassel & Elizabeth (DeFur) Britton.
Brooks Willie 17 Apr 1872 10 Aug 1872 Son of Joshus Miles & Sarah Jane (Rogers) Brooks.   No headstone found. 
Butler Anna W 27 Feb 1860 26 Sep 1879 Daughter of Sherewood H & Elizabeth (Hill) Butler.    
Butler Bryant B abt 1825
- Husband of Jemima S "Gemina" (Trammel) Butler, 1st, married 17 Feb 1847; and Lelitha "Telitha" (Stallings) Butler, 2nd, married 1 Dec 1856.
   
Butler Elizabeth - 9 Feb 1862 nee Hill.  Wife of Sherewood H Butler.  Married 4 Aug 1853.

Daughter of Wiley & Sarah Hill.

Aged:  33 y. 5 m. 12 d.
   
Butler Emaline Creek 1849 15 Aug 1934 nee Creek.  Wife of Enoch J Butler.  Married 3 Dec 1868.
   
Butler Enoch J 1847 4 Apr 1918 Husband of Emaline (Creek) Butler.  Married 3 Dec 1868.

Son of Bryant B & Jemima S "Gemina" (Trammel) Butler
   
Butler Jemima S
"Gemina"
abt 1825
- nee Trammel.  First wife of Bryant B Butler.  Married 17 Feb 1847.

Daughter of James P Trammel.
   
Butler Jordan - 17 Apr 1838 Husband of Susan Butler.

Son of Jourdon Butler.

Aged:  41 y. 10 m. 18 d.
 
 
Butler Lilithia S
"Telitha"
- - nee Stallings.  Second wife of Bryan Butler.  Married 1 Dec 1856.     
Butler Mary
"Mollie"  
8 Feb 1879 21 Mar 1962 nee Kelton.  Wife of William Butler.  Married 28 Sep 1902.

Daughter
of Jonathan T & Margaret (Nash) Kelton.
  No headstone found. 
Butler Ruth "Rutha"
abt 1835
aft 1920
nee Upshaw.  Wife of Sinclair M Butler, 1st, married 15 Sep 1850; Martin, 2nd; and John H Overton, 3rd.
   
Butler Sherewood H - 19 Jan 1861 Husband of Elizabeth (Hill) Butler.  Married 4 Aug 1853.

Son of Jordan & Susan Butler.

Aged:  43 y. 9 m. 19 d.
 
 
Butler Sinclair M
abt 1820
bef 1870
First husband of Rutha (Upshaw) Butler Martin Overton.

Son of Jordan & Susan Butler.
   
Butler Stephen 1808 1863 Second husband of Nancy Jane (Vandeveer) Cox Butler, married 7 Sep 1844. 

Note:  C. Cox book reports his first wife is also buried here.
   
Butler Susan - 1 Jan 1859 Wife of Jordon Butler. 

Aged 67 y. 9 m. 15 d.
   
Butler Virtis V 1910 1917 Son of William & Mary "Mollie" (Kelton) Butler.    
Butler William 5 Sep 1860 19 Nov 1956 Husband of Mary "Mollie" (Kelton) Butler.  Married 28 Sep 1902.

Son of Enoch J & Emaline (Creek) Butler.
  No headstone found. 
Butler Willie - 1828      
Cartwright Albert S
29 Sep 1847 29 Mar 1879 Husband of Freelove (Reeves) Cartwright.  Married 5 Feb 1867.

Son of Samuel & Sarah (Hunter) Cartwright.
 
 
Cartwright Elizabeth Ellen Ramsey 19 Apr 1856 12 Mar 1946 nee Cox.  Wife of Thomas F Cartwright, 1st, married 6 Nov 1873; and Henry C Ramsey, 2nd, married 9 Dec 1914.. 

Daughter of Stinson & Martha Sarah (Ramsey) Cox.
 
Cartwright Samuel Marion 21 Feb 1822 9 Jul 1878 Husband of Sarah (Hunter) Cartwright.  Married 2 Oct 1845.

Son of Samuel K & Jane (Rogers) Cartwright.
   
Cartwright Sarah 16 Dec 1827 27 Jul 1905 nee Hunter.  Wife of Samuel Marion Cartwright.  Married 2 Oct 1845.
 
Cartwright Thomas F 29 May 1850 17 May 1909 First husband of Elizabeth Ellen (Cox) Cartwright Ramsey.  Married 6 Nov 1873.

Son of Presley & Lydia Mariah (Moye) Cartwright.
   
Cox
Anna E
-
1 Nov 1860
Daughter of Silas & Martha (Williams) Cox.

Aged:  1 m. 23 d.

Record of burial from C. Cox book.
Cox Emily Florence "Emma" 10 Apr 1859 24 Apr 1881 Daughter of George Whiting & Sarena May (Forcum) Cox.   No headstone found. 
Cox George Whiting 17 Sep 1826 7 Jun 1902 Husband of Sarena May (Forcum) Cox.  Married 26 Nov 1846.

Son
of Joseph "General Joe" & Elizabeth (Hunsaker) Cox.
   
Cox
Infant
-
15 Mar 1863
Infant son of Elijah & Elizabeth (Price) Cox.

Cox James Hamilton
"Claw Hammer"
18 May 1837 1 May 1911 Husband of  Sophronia Agnes (Walker) Cox.  Married 29 Jan 1863.

Son of Joseph "Jody" & Nancy (Cox) Cox.
   
Cox John
"Double Head"
11 May 1773 9 Jan 1854 Husband of Sarah Ann "Sally" (Rogers) Cox.    
CoxJohn Craig11 Jan 18481 Jun 1900Son of Silas Cox & Elizabeth (Craig) Cox Hume.  
Cox Josephus -
20 Apr 1881 Son of Stinson & Martha Sarah (Ramsey) Cox.

Aged:  21 y. 3 m. 17 d.
  No headstone found. 
Cox
Louisa
3 Oct 1874
12 Sep 1878
Daughter of William J & Mary C (Johnson) Cox.

Record of burial from C. Cox book.
Cox Louisa E
- 3 Apr 1867 nee Butler.  First wife of Elihu Cox.  Married 23 Mar 1848.

Daughter of Armstead & Margaret W "Peggy" (Green) Butler.

Aged:  39 y. 13 d.
   
Cox Martha Sarah   27 Jan 1830 Apr 1909 nee Ramsey.  Wife of Stinson Cox.  Married 11 May 1853.

Daughter of James & Edith (Fletcher) Ramsey.
 
Cox Sarah Ann
"Sally"
17 Jan 1779 22 Jan 1855 nee Rogers.  Wife of John "Double Head' Cox.  
Cox Sarah Caroline   27 Apr 1847 23 Sep 1874 nee Hunter.  Wife of Thomas Price Cox.  Married 4 Sep 1866.

Aged:  27 Y's 4 M's. 26 Ds.
 
 
Cox Sarah Elizabeth 8 Nov 1847 7 Feb 1866 Daughter of George Whiting & Sarena May (Forcum) Cox.    
Cox Sarena May   6 Sep 1825 4 Aug 1902 nee Forcum.  Wife of George Whiting Cox.  Married 26 Nov 1846.
 
Cox Silas M 4 Jul 1817 28 Aug 1864 First husband of Elizabeth A (Craig) Cox Hume.  Married 15 Oct 1846.

Son of John "Double Head" & Sarah "Sally" (Rogers) Cox.
 
 
Cox Sophronia Agnes   18 Aug 1845 21 Apr 1917 nee Walker.  Wife of James Hamilton Cox.  Married 29 Jan 1863.  
Cox Stinson - 5 Jun 1896 Husband of Martha (Ramsey) Cox.  Married 11 May 1853.

Son of Joseph "General Joe" & Elizabeth (Hunsinger) Cox.

Aged:  72 y. 4 m. 29 d.
   
Cox Thomas G
"Gun"
Apr 1801 Mar 1867 Husband of Sally (Price) Cox, 1st, married 31 Mar 1825; and Sarena (Bozeman) Rogers Cox, 2nd, married 6 Mar 1846.

 Son of John "Double Head" & Sarah "Sally" (Rogers) Cox. 
   
Cox
Thomas Price
8 Nov 1843
-
Husband of Sarah Caroline (Hunter) Cox, Married 4 Sep 1866.

Son of Elijah B & Elizabeth (Price) Cox.

Pvt. Co. A, 91st Reg. Indiana Vols.  Enrolled 10 Aug 1862 at Wadesville, Indiana.  Mustered out at Salisbury, North Carolina. Civil War

Record of burial from C. Cox book.
Craig John Benton 5 Jan 1835 - Husband of Amanda E (Johnson) Craig, 1st, married 12 Mar 1865; and second husband of Mary E (Cox)  Stephens Craig.  Married 16 May 1892 in Vanderburgh County, Indiana.

Son of Jesse Richley & Mary "Polly" (Smith) Craig.
   
Craig Mary E Cox 24 Dec 1841 18 Feb 1901 nee Cox.  Wife of Orien W Stephens, 1st, married 8 Oct 1874; and second wife of John Benton Craig, 2nd, married 16 May 1892 in Vanderburgh County, Indiana.

Daughter of Silas M & Elizabeth A (Craig) Cox.
 
Cross
Mary E
-
12 Oct 1883
nee Roberts.  Wife of James W Gross.  Married 1 Aug 1870. 

Daughter of Joshua & Matilda (Flora) Roberts.

Aged:  30 y. 10 m. 24 d.

Note:  This surname has previously reported as "Gross."

Cross
Infant
15 Nov 1877
15 Nov 1877
Infant daughter of James W & Mary E (Roberts) Cross.

Note:  This surname has previously reported as "Gross."

Cross
Infant
"Baby"
-
10 Aug 1883
Infant son of James W & Mary E (Roberts) Gross.

Note:  This surname has previously reported as "Gross."

DeFur Bedy
"Biddy"
20 Oct 1804 11 Jul 1893 nee Roberts.   Wife of Roswell DeFur.  Married 27 Dec 1821.  
DeFurCharles
--Son of Isaiah & Nancy A (Roberts) DeFur.
  
DeFur Charles E "Charlie"
5 Jan 1896 10 Apr 1897 Son of Thomas E & Mary L (Kelley) DeFur.
   
DeFur
Isaiah
5 Sep 1836
19 Dec 1870
First husband of Nancy A (Roberts) DeFur Anderson.  Married 16 Aug 1858.

Son of Roswell & Bedy (Roberts) DeFur.

Pvt., Co. C, 60 Reg. Indiana Infantry, Civil War.  Enrolled at Wadesville, Posey, Indiana.  Age:  26.  Discharged at New Albany, Clark, Indiana on 26 Sep 1862 (Disability.)

Note:  Name found as "Isiah (Isaac) Defer" in the Indiana State Civil War records.

DeFur
Jesse N
21 Dec 1852
25 Oct 1872
Son of William & Olive Jane (Reeves) DeFur.

DeFur
Joel
23 Nov 1856
29 Aug 1858
Son of John A DeFur & Martha (Roberts) DeFur Simpson.

DeFur John A - 3 Jun 1864 First husband of Martha (Roberts) DeFur Simpson.  Married 7 Feb 1856. 

Son of Roswell & Bedy (Roberts) DeFur.

Aged:  31 y. 2 m. 14 d.
   
DeFur
Julia A
21 Feb 1891
26 Feb 1891
Daughter of Levi & Milly J (Harmon) DeFur.

DeFur Leander 15 Dec 1831 2 Feb 1919 Husband of Matilda Jane (Kelley) DeFur.  Married 21 Apr 1890.

Son of Roswell & Bedy (Roberts) DeFur.
   
DeFur
Mary E
9 Sep 1855
25 Nov 1858
Daughter of William & Olive J (Reeves) DeFur.

DeFur Mary L   14 Nov 1864 19 Sep 1928 nee Kelley.  Wife of Thomas E DeFur.  Married 23 Nov 1886.

Daughter of John & Mary (Campbell) Kelley.
   
DeFur Matilda Jane   20 Nov 1858 1 Apr 1913 nee Kelley.  Wife of Leander DeFur.  Married 21 Apr 1890.
 
DeFur Oscar R 25 Jan 1893 25 Apr 1914 Son of Thomas E & Mary L (Kelley) DeFur.    
DeFur Thomas E 21 Aug 1862 11 Feb 1943 Husband of Mary L (Kelley) DeFur.  Married 23 Nov 1886.

Son of John A DeFur & Martha (Roberts) DeFur Simpson
 
DeFur William B - 2 Apr 1864 Son of John A DeFur & Martha (Roberts) DeFur Simpson.

Aged:  4 y. 6 m. 9 d.
 
 
Durling
Andrew J
-
9 Jul 1865
Husband of Nancy Ann (Duckworth) Durling, 1st, married 30 Dec 1839; and Sarah Jane (Cavett) Durlingm 2nd, married 28 Nov 1847.

Aged:  55 y. 11 m. 15 d.

Record of burial from C. Cox book.
Durling
Sarah Jane
-
23 Oct 1868
nee Cavett.  Second wife of Andrew J Durling.  Married 28 Nov 1847.

Daughter of Andrew & Nancy (Lowe) Cavett.

Aged:  45 y. 2 m. 5 d.

Record of burial from C. Cox book.
Graddy Sarah "Sallie" Owens - 18 Feb 1885 nee Owens.  Wife of Durham Graddy.  Married 2 Sep 1830.      No headstone found.
Gwaltney Infant  - 18 Jul 1875 Infant daughter of J H & N R Gwaltney.

  Aged:  7 days.
 
 
Gwaltney Job Calvin  18 Feb 1834 15 Oct 1879 Husband of Narcissa (Damond) Gwaltney.  Married 29 Sep 1864.

Son of Thomas & Nancy (Reeder) Gwaltney.
   
Gwaltney Matilda Jane   30 May 1843 10 Nov 1886 Daughter of Thomas & Nancy (Reeder) Gwaltney.  
 
Gwaltney Nancy   7 Oct 1802 18 Jun 1883 nee Reeder.  Wife of Thomas Gwaltney.  Married 13 Nov 1818.

Daughter of Simon & Elizabeth (Calvin) Reeder.
   
Gwaltney Narcissa 1843 Jun 1870 nee Damon.  Wife of Job Calvin Gwaltney.  Married 29 Sep 1864.
 
Gwaltney Thomas 13 Dec 1796 7 Jul 1873 Husband of Nancy (Reeder) Gwaltney.  Married 13 Nov 1818.

Son of John & Anna "Ann" (Murphy) Gwaltney, Sr.
   
Hayes
Anna
28 Jul 1802
19 Aug 1885
nee Cox.  Wife of John Hayes, Jr.  Married 30 Jul 1829.

Record of burial from C. Cox book.
Hayes John, Jr
28 Oct 1805 27 Apr 1872 Husband of Anna (Cox) Hayes.  Married 30 Jul 1829.

Son of John & Nancy Elizabeth (Campbell) Hayes, Sr.
 
Hayes
John
-
15 Dec 1862
Son of John & Anna (Cox) Hayes.

Aged:  15 y. 11 m. 22 d.

Hume Elizabeth Ann 19 Aug 1825 20 Jan 1901 nee Craig.  Wife of Silas M Cox, 1st, married 15 Oct 1846; and William Hume, 2nd.

Daughter of John H & Sarah (Early) Craig.
 
Hunter Fannie C
1858 May 1930 nee Rister.  Wife of James Richard Hunter.  Married 9 Nov 1884.

Daughter of George & Eliza (Gwaltney) Rister.
 
Hunter Fredonia M   11 Aug 1874 28 Feb 1901 nee Stallings.  Wife of George Washington Hunter.  Married 4 Nov 1891.

Daughter of Francis M & Henrietta (Walton) Stallings.
   
Hunter George Washington 4 Aug 1863 5 Feb 1916 Husband of Fredonia M (Stallings) Hunter.  Married 4 Nov 1891.

Son of James & Nancy Jane (Williams) Hunter.
   
Hunter James   30 May 1820 9 Aug 1890 Husband of Nancy Jane (Williams) Hunter.  Married 13 Oct 1846.

Son of William & Margaret (Nash) Hunter, III.   

James Hunter died last Saturday August 9, after a long spell of sickness, at his residence 6 miles east of this place. He leaves six sons and two daughters and a host of other relatives and friends to mourn his loss. His remains were taken to Bethlehem on Sunday, followed by a very large crowd of relatives and friends. Mr. Hunter was highly esteemed by all who knew him, always jovial and kind-hearted. He was a leading Democrat and a well-to-do farmer. He was aged about 70 years. (Poseyville News 16 August 1890)
 
 
Hunter James Richard 16 Oct 1854 23 Apr 1913 Husband of Fannie C (Rister) Hunter.  Married 9 Nov 1884.

Son of James & Nancy Jane (Williams) Hunter.
 
Hunter Nancy Jane Williams 14 Oct 1825 19 May 1879 nee Williams.  Wife of James Hunter.  Married 13 Oct 1846.

Daughter of Urban & Nancy (Johnson) Williams.
   
Inglesaul
Christina
17 Jun 1848
17 Mar 1889
Wife of Edward Inglesaul.

Record of burial from C. Cox book.
Inglesaul
Rosa Ellen
13 Aug 1872
12 Feb 1887
Daughter of Edward & Christina Inglesaul.

Johnson Dicy 30 Nov 1848 2 Jul 1871 Daughter of Moses & Elizabeth (Stallings) Johnson.    
Johnson Elizabeth Stallings 22 Mar 1813 12 Apr 1889 Wife of Harbert Stallings, Sr, 1st; and Moses Johnson, 2nd, married 15 Apr 1839.
 
Johnson Moses 18 Mar 1817 9 May 1874 Second husband of Elizabeth Stallings Johnson.  Married 15 Apr 1839.

Son of Thomas Henry & Susan Stallings Johnson.
   
Kelton
Jonathan T
1845
27 Mar 1919
Husband of Margaret (Nash) Kelton, 1st, married 26 Oct 1869; and Louisa Gwaltney Kelton, 2nd, married 22 Feb 1894.

Son of Thomas & Sarah (Persons) Kelton.

Pvt. Co. C, 60th Reg. Indiana Infantry.  Enlisted at Evansville, Vanderburgh, Indiana on 14 Feb 1862.  Discharged at end of term, 21 Mar 1865 at Indianapolis, Marion, Indiana.

Record of burial from C. Cox book.

Note:  He is actually buried in the Indiana Soldiers Home Cemetery at West Lafayette, Tippecanoe County Indiana.
"Plot:  Area WWI, Section South Centeral, Row C, Grave 10."
(See Find A Grave Memorial #51420623.)
Kelton Margaret Nash 1 Aug 1845 Bef 1894 nee Nash.  First wife of Jonathan T Kelton.  Married 26 Oct 1869. 

Daughter of Jessie & Nancy (Montgomery) Nash, Jr.

 
"STONE SAYS 1814 BUT DEFINITELY IN ERROR PER THE 1880 CENSUS." 
   
Kight Albert 5 Nov 1855 29 Dec 1878 Son of Jonathan & Elizabeth Ann (Cavett) Kight.  
 
KightAllie18 Sep 18??
3 Jan 18??
Son of ? N & T E Kight.

Note:  Carving is very difficult to read.
 
 
Kight Anna   - 22 Dec 1851 Daughter of Ezekiel & Rebecca (Murphy) Kight.

Aged:  21 y. 10 m.
   
Kight Cornelius - 5 Jan 1851 Son of Ezekiel & Rebecca (Murphy) Kight. 

Aged:  17 y. 9 m. 7 d.  
   
Kight Elizabeth Ann 22 Feb 1826 1 Jun 1884 nee Cavett.  Wife of Johnathan Kight.  Married 24 Aug 1848.

Daughter of Andrew & Nancy (Lowe) Cavett.
 
 
Kight
Emily
-
-
nee Endicott.  Wife of Stephan Kight.

Record of burial from C. Cox book.
Kight Ezekiel - 11 Aug 1841 Husband of Rebecca (Murphy) Kight.  Married 13 Apr 1809 in Muhlenberg County, Kentucky.

Son of Stephen & Bethany (Merritt) Kight.

Aged:  53 y. 7 m. 2 d.

War of 1812, Battle of Tippecanoe.
.  
Kight George - 1940      
Kight
Infant
?
?
Infant son of J H & M J Kight


KightInfant 7 Feb 18631 Mar 1863Infant son of Johnathan & Elizabeth Ann (Cavett) Kight.  
Kight James H 4 Nov 1851 25 Nov 1873 Son of Johnathan & Elizabeth Ann (Cavett) Kight.    
Kight Johnathan 17 May 1824 6 Dec 1877 Husband of Elizabeth Ann (Cavett) Knight.   Married 24 Aug 1848.

Son of Ezekiel & Rebecca (Murphy) Kight.
 
 
Kight
Polly Ann
29 Nov 1819
19 Mar 1846
nee Murphy.  Wife of Jesse Kight.  Married 1 Jun 1845.

Kight Rebecca  - 27 Oct 1870 nee Murphy.  Wife of Ezekiel Kight.  Married 13 Apr 1809 in Muhlenberg County, Kentucky.

Daughter of Thomas & Adah Murphy.

Aged:  82 y. 9 m. 13 d.
   
Kight
Stephen
-
10 Apr 1846
Husband of Emily (Endicott) Kight.  Married 4 Sep 1834.

Son of Ezekiel & Rebecca (Murphy) Kight.

Aged:  36 y.3 m.3 d.

Kight
Thomas
-
-
Husband of ? Kight.

Record of burial from C. Cox book.
Kight
?
-
-
Grandchild of Thomas Kight
Record of burial from C. Cox book.
Kight
Thomas, Mrs.
-
-
Wife of Thomas Kight.

Record of burial from C. Cox book.
Lee George W 23 Jan 1822 4 Apr 1854 Husband of Margaret (Wylie) Lee.  Married 2 May 1847.

Son of Joseph & Elizabeth "Betsy" (Edwards) Lee.

Note:  There is a later monument for him and his wife at Old Beech Cemetery, Lynn Township, Posey, Indiana.
   
Moye Jane - 25 Dec 1857 nee Butler.  Wife of John D Moye. 

Aged:  34 y. 9 m. 28 d.
   
Murphey Aaron 25 Feb 1809 24 Jan 1878 Husband of Elizabeth Amelia "Milly" (Williams) Murphey.  Married 31 Jul 1828.

Son of James & Elizabeth (Boone) Murphy
   
Murphy Aaron Thomas 22 Jun 1848 24 Nov 1892 Husband of Amanda (Burnett) Thomas.  Married 20 Oct 1870.

Son of Aaron & Elizabeth Amelia "Milly" (Williams) Murphy.
 
Murphy Amanda 1847 1923 nee Burnett.  Wife of Aaron Thomas Murphy.  Married 20 Oct 1870.
 
Murphy Amelia A - 29 Jul 1858 Daughter of Elias Murphy & Frances R (Ramsey) Murphy Passmore. 

Aged:  1 y. 7 d.
   
Murphy Edith E - 14 May 1882 Daughter of Elias Murphy & Frances R (Ramsey) Murphy Passmore. 

Aged:  22 y. 9 m. 22 d.
   
Murphy Elias - 11 Oct 1860 First husband of Frances "Frankey" R (Ramsey) Passmore.   Married 9 Jan 1851.

Son of Aaron & Elizabeth Amelia "Milly" (Williams) Murphy.

 Aged:  30 y. 7 m.
28 d.
   
MurpheyElizabeth Amelia
"Milly"
4 Feb 181031 Apr 1902nee Williams.  Wife of Aaron Murphey.  Married 31 Jul 1828.

Daugter of Bennett & Mary "Polly" (Martin) Williams.
  
Murphy Henry E 3 Aug 1869 28 Sep 1870 Son of John C & Ann L Murphy.

Aged:  1 Yr. 1 M & 25 Dy's.
   
Murphy James B - 6 Dec 1860 Son of Elias & Frances R (Ramsey) Murphy.

 
Aged:  8 y. 10 m. 5 d.
 
 
Nash
Daisy
18 Aug 1879
18 Aug 1879


Record of burial from C. Cox book.
Nash Jesse - 16 Feb 1878 Husband of Nancy Jane (Montgomery) Nash.  Married 27 Jul 1826.

Son of Jesse & Sarah (Cavett) Nash.

Aged:  76 y. 2 m.

Captain of Co. C, 60th Indiana Vol., promoted to Major.
.  
Nash Nancy Jane
- 12 Jul 1881 nee Montgomery.  Wife of Jesse Nash.  Married 27 Jul 1826.

Daughter of Samuel & Hannah (Copeland) Montgomery.

Aged:  79 y. 8 m. 17 d.

 
 
Nelson Eliza E
- 4 May 1864 nee DeFur.  Wife of Charles W Nelson.  Married 10 Jul 1856.

Daughter of Roswell & Bedy (Roberts) Defur.

 
Aged:  26 y. 3 m. 16 d.
 
 
Nelson
Isaac N
-
17 Oct 1867
Son of George W & Mary J Nelson. 

Aged:  3 y. 1 m. 17 d.

Record of burial from C. Cox book.
Owens Flavius, Sr 7 Feb 1846 12 Dec 1904 Husband of Paulina Jane (Cox) Owens.  Married 15 Apr 1875.

Son of James George & Sarah Ann (Saltzman) Owens.
   
Owens Paulina Jane  13 Oct 1854 8 Dec 1943 nee Cox.  Wife of Flavius Owens.    Married 15 Apr 1875.

Daughter of George & Sarah May (Forcum) Cox.
 
Passmore Frances R "Frankey"   - 11 Aug 1864 nee Ramsey.  Wife of Elias Murphy, 1st, narried 9 Jan 1851; and John F Passmore, 2nd, married 3 Oct 1861 . 

Daughter of James Thomas & Edith (Fletcher) Ramsey.

Aged:  36 y. 18 d.
    
 
Passmore John F
1826 1862 Second husband of Frances R (Ramsey) Passmore.  Married 3 Oct 1861.

Son of William & M Christiana (Wood) Passmore.
  No headstone found. 
Pfister Clara R 6 Dec 1887 23 Aug 1888 Daughter of Louis & Lina Pfister.  
 
Pfister
Eugene
27 Jan 1877
14 Sep 1898
Son of Michael & Bilzona (Harris) Pfister.
Aged:  1 Y. 2 M. 18 D

Pfister
Infant
21 Feb 1872
21 Feb 1872
Twin daughter of Michael & Rachel H (Williams) Pfister.

"One was dead when born..."

Pfister
Infant
21 Feb 1872
23 Feb 1872
Twin daughter of Michael & Rachel H (Williams) Pfister.

"...the other died ...2 dys."

Pfister
Rachael H
-
4 May 1873
nee Williams.  Wife of M Pfister.  Daughter of W & L Williams.

Aged 26 Yrs. 9 Mos. 24 dys.

Pfister
William Francis
-
24 Aug 1873
Son of Michael & Rachel H (Williams) Pfister. 

Aged:  3 ms. 26 dys.

Reeder Mary Angeline
1833
13 Jun 1835
1863
30 Nov 1865
nee Donovan.  Wife of Elisah York, 1st, married 11 Feb 1851; and James Urbin Reeder, 2nd, married 23 Oct 1860.
   
Reeder James Urbin abt 1839
29 Nov 1862
Second husband of Mary Angeline (Donovan) York Reeder.  Married 23 Oct 1860.

Pvt., Co. A, 91st Indiana Infantry.  Enrolled at New Harmony, Posey, Indiana on 10 Aug 1862.  Age:  23. Discharged "Died at Smithland, Kentucky" on
29 Nov 1862
 
Reeves
James
13 Apr 1847
24 Feb 1867
Son of Milton & Elizabeth Reeves.


Reeves
John M
-
24 Feb 1863
Son of Milton & Elizabeth D (Cox)  Reeves.

Aged:  19 y. 6 m. 18 d.

Reeves Richard H abt 1845
-
Husband of Mary A (Jones) Reeves.  Married 22 Jan 1861.

Son of William W & Elizabeth W (Shepherd) Reeves.

Pvt., Co. F, 80th Indiana Infantry.  Enrolled at Evansville, Vanderburgh, Indiana on 30 Jan 1865.  Mustered out at Charlotte, North Carolina on 29 Aug 1865.
 
Reif
Elizabeth
9 Oct 1813
22 Oct 1878
nee Shepherd.  Wife of William W Sheperd, 1st, married 13 Jun 1833; and Franklin Reif, 2nd, married 4 Jul 1861

Note:  Stone has been reset rather deep in concrete to the left of her husband's stone.
 
Reif
Franklin
-
16 Jul 1887
Husband of Elizabeth Reeves Reif.  Married 4 Jul 1861.

Aged:  67 years.
 
Rister
Angeline
abt 1845
-
nee Britton.  Wife of James Reister.  Married 24 Dec 1863. 

Daughter of Hassel & Elizabeth (DeFur) Britton


Rister Elizabeth Jane "Eliza"  27 Nov 1830 5 Jan 1902 nee Gwaltney.  Wife of George Washington Rister.   Married 4 Feb 1854.

Daughter of Amariah & Sarah (Reeder) Gwaltney.

Mrs. Rister, the aged mother of J.A. and C. Rister was fatally burned last Saturday afternoon at the home of her daughter, Mrs. Richard Hunter, east of New Harmony. At the time of the accident, Mrs. Rister was the only occupant of the house, with the exception of a small grandson, the other members of the family being at church. She was standing in front of a large fire place when she noticed that her skirts were also aflame. Before she could tear her clothing away the flames had enveloped her body and frantic with fear she ran through the house which had the effect of causing the flames to burn swifter. The young boy acted with great presence of mind and tried to drown out the flames with a bucket of water but his grandmother's motions rendered aid inaffective. By this time the fire had full possession of the victim's garments and as they burned loose fell to the floor where they were consumed. (New Harmony Times 6 January 1922) 
   
Rister
James
-
-
Husband of Angeline (Britton) Reister.  Married 24 Dec 1863. 

Rister John Cophrenes 1862 1926 Husband of Martha Alice "Mattie" (Hunter) Rister.  Married 13 Aug 1882.

Son of George Washington & Elizabeth Jane "Eliza" (Gwaltney) Rister.
   
Rister Margaret Jane  - 6 Apr 1899 nee Hunter.  Wife of James Rister.  Married 13 Feb 1879.

Daughter of James & Nancy Jane (Williams) Hunter.

Aged:  42 y. 6 m. 24 d.
   
Rister Martha Alice  "Mattie" 7 Sep 1858 21 Feb 1937 nee Hunter.  Wife of John Cophrenes Rister.  Married 13 Aug 1882.

Daughter of James & Nancy Jane (Williams) Hunter.
 
Roberts Harriet 24 Sep 1845 27 Jan 1900 nee Cox.  Wife of Thomas Todd Roberts.  Married 26 Feb 1863.

Daughter of Joseph "Jody" & Nancy Cox.
   
Roberts
Infant
8 Mar 1888
8 Mar 1888
Infant son of Thomas T & Harriett (Cox) Roberts.

Roberts Joshua
"Jack"
1869 20 Jan 1939 Husband of Lorettia (Boswell) Roberts.  Married 26 Mar 1898.

Son of Thomas Todd & Harriet (Cox) Roberts. 
   
Roberts Joshua 10 Mar 1813 2 Sep 1870 Husband of Matilda (Flora)  Roberts.  Married 22 Dec 1835.

Son of John & Nancy (Cox) Roberts.
 

 
Roberts
Lawrence L
30 Jun 1893
30 Jun 1895
Son of Warren & Sarahell N (Walker) Roberts.

Roberts Matilda   10 May 1813 25 Jan 1892 nee Flora. Wife of Joshua Roberts.  Married 22 Dec 1835.
   
Roberts Thomas Todd 20 Jan 1842 28 Jul 1890 Husband of Harriet (Cox) Roberts.  Married 26 Feb 1863.

Son of Joshua & Matilda (Flora) Roberts.
 
 
Roberts Virgil 1877 1943 Son of Thomas Todd & Harriet (Cox) Roberts.     
Rogers William Elisha 1839 23 Oct 1865 Confederate Soldier    No headstone found. 
Schettler
Mary Ann
-
-
nee Butler.  Wife of Jacob Schettler.  Married 16 Jan 1849.

No headstone.
Record of burial from C. Cox book.
Scott
Birten
"Burton"
"Barton"
"Britton"

11 Jun 1832
26 Jun 1862
Husband of Elizabeth J (Cox) Scott.  Married 22 Jan 1854.

Son of James & Polly  (Marvel) Scott.

Scott
Sarah Caroline
20 May 1857
6 Mar 1881
Daughter of Burton & Elizabeth J "Betsy" (Cox)  Scott.



Scott
Elizabeth J "Betsy"
23 Apr 1833
5 Feb 1902
nee Cox.  Wife of Burton Scott.  Married 22 Jan 1854.

Daughter of Johnathan & Elizabeth (Hayes) Cox, Sr.

Simpson Martha Roberts 23 Dec 1837 30 Apr 1899 nee Roberts.  Wife of John A DeFur, 1st, married 7 Feb 1837; and Richard H Simpson, 2nd, married 8 Mar 1866. 

Daughter of J & M Roberts. 

"Joined the Regular Baptist Church 1862 and remainded a constant member until death."
   
Stallings
Alexander
31 Aug 1857
1 Jul 1889
Son of Lewis & Sarah Ellen (Reeves) Stallings.

Record of burial from C. Cox book.
Stallings
Della
21 Dec 1873
23 Jan 1874
Daughter of Lewis & Sarah Ellen (Reeves) Stallings.
Record of burial from C. Cox book.
Stallings Dolly Jan 1884 Jan 1884 Daughter of Francis M & Henrietta (Gwaltney) Stallings.      
Stallings Francis Marion 23 Nov 1838 3 Nov 1919 Husband of Henrietta (Gwaltney) Stallings.  Married 23 Oct 1860.

Son of Willis & Matilda (Harvey) Stallings.
   
Stallings Harbert, Jr 26 Apr 1837 17 Dec 1860 Son of Harbert Stallings, Sr & Elizabeth Stallings Johnson.    
Stallings Henrietta 10 Jan 1841 6 Jul 1911 nee Gwaltney.  Wife of Francis Marion Stallings.  Married 23 Oct 1860.

Daughter of Thomas & Nancy (Reeder) Gwaltney.
 
Stallings Leroy W 11 Sep 1873 17 Aug 1874 Son of Francis Marion & Henrietta (Gwaltney) Stallings.    
 
Stallings
Lewis
9 Oct 1824
1 Jul 1907
Husband of Sarah Ellen (Reeves) Stallings.  Married 12 Jun 1851.

Son of Henry B & Mary (Wilson) Stallings.

Record of burial from C. Cox book.
Stallings Martha J 17 Feb 1840 5 Nov 1902  Daughter of Henry & Mary "Polly" (Wilson) Stallings.
   
Stallings
Sarah Ellen
2 Oct 1835
30 Mar 1884
nee Reeves.  Wife of Lewis Stallings.  Married 12 Jun 1851.

Daughter of Milton & Elizabeth (Cox) Reeves.

Record of burial from C. Cox book.
Stallings Sarah E  8 Jan 1869 23 Aug 1870 Daughter of Francis Marion & Henrietta (Gwaltney) Stallings.    
Stallings
Virgil
28 Jun 1871
21 Apr 1905
Son of Lewis & Sarah Ellen (Reeves) Stallings.

Record of burial from C. Cox book.
StallingsWilliam J
8 Jan 186923 Aug 1870Son of Francis Marion & Henrietta (Gwaltney) Stallings. 


Stallings William J 14 Feb 1862
12 Jun 1871
Son of Harbert C Stallings, Sr & Elizabeth J Stallings Johnson.    
Streamer Mary Pearl 11 Mar 1889 4 Apr 1907 Daughter of James R & Martha Anne (Davis) Streamer. 

OBITUARY
DEATH OF A FRIEND
It is with profound regret that we chronicle the death at 8:30 o'clock of Miss Mary Streamer, the second daughter of Mr. and Mrs. James Streamer, and a prominent young lady of this community. The deceased was 18 years 22 days of age, and Mary was a good and kind hearted girl.
She had many friends and was loved by all who knew her. Mary leaves a father, mother, three sisters and four brothers to mourn her departure. Mary's girl friends were the pall bearers. They were Misses Eva Wiley, Carrie Hein, Edith Baker, Anna Blaylock, Nellie Walker and Lizzie Hein. The funeral took place at Bethlehem church on Saturday, April 6, at 11 0'clock, Rev. A. A. Shoultz conducting the services. The remains were laid to rest in the Bethlehem cemetery.
   
Streamer Thomas W 26 Nov 1887 27 Mar 1888 Son of James R & Martha Anne (Davis) Streamer.    
Torrance Lawrence - 1929      
TorranceLawrence, Mrs.
--  Record of burial from C. Cox book.
VarnerChristina
17 Jun 1848
17 Mar 1899
nee Stallings.  Wife of Francis Marion Varner.  Married 16 Apr 1876.

Daughter of Willis & Elizabeth Stallings.
 
Wade Abner - 17 Sep 1868 Consort of Sarah (Murphy) Wade.  Married 2 May 1861.

Son of Joshua P & Dorcas (Ricketts) Wade.

Age:  28 y. 2 m. 15 d.
   
Wade Abner J 2 Feb 1864 3 Jun 1880 Son of Abner G & Sarah (Murphy) Wade.  
 
WadeDorilla ?
21 Dec 1866
24 Jan 1869
Daughter of Joshua D & Augusta A (Hunter) Wade.

Note:  Not sure of given name!
 
 
Wade Isaac Murphy, Esq.
- 19 Jun 1863 Husband of Sarah "Sallie" (Wilson) Wade.  Married 3 Jan 1828.

Son of Joshua Carter & Polly (Conner) Wade.

Aged:   56 y. 4 m. 5 d.
 
 
Wade James C 25 Feb 1862 6 Feb 1880 Son of Abner & Sarah (Murphy) Wade.    
Wade Martha Alice 
1 Feb 1835 7 Aug 1880 nee Murphy.  Wife of Eli Wade.  Married 9 Mar 1859.

Daughter of Aaron & Elizabeth Amelia (Williams) Murphy.
 
 
Wade Mary A - 4 Oct 1865 Daughter of Eli & Martha Alice (Hunter) Wade. 

Age:  4 Ys.. 2 Ms 24 Ds.
   
Wade Sarah
"Sallie" 
14 May 1805 25 Jan 1886 nee Wilson.  Wife of Isaac Murphy Wade.  Married 3 Jan 1828.

Daughter of Lewis & Mary (Moore) Wilson.
   
Webb  Infant 20 Mar 1907 20 Mar 1907 Infant son of A J & F L Webb.  
 
Williams Annie J 1850 1910 nee McReynolds.  Wife of Joseph T Williams.  Married 4 Jul 1878. 

Daughter of John W & Elisabeth McReynolds.
   
Williams
Evaline
-
10 Apr 1866
nee Gwaltney.  Wife of Jeremiah Williams.  Married 1 Jan 1862.

Daughter of Thomas & Nancy (Reeder) Gwaltney.

Aged: 28 y. 9 m. 29 d.

Williams Joseph T 1856 1938 Husband of Annie J (McReynolds) Williams.  Married 4 Jul 1878.
 
Willis
Abner
20 Apr 1796
23 May 1874
Husband of Nancy Ann (Hayes) Willis. 

Son of Ephriam & Elizabeth (Joyner) Willis.


Willis
Nancy Ann
-
20 May 1878
nee Hayes.  Husband of Abner Willis.

Daughter of John & Elizabeth (Campbell) Hayes.

Aged:  80 y.





View of cemetery entrance