| Name | Birthdate | Age | Height | Build | Eyes | Hair | Birthplace | Residence | Occupation | Relative Mentioned | |||||||||
| Umpleby | Harry | 28 | Jan | 1896 | 21 | Tall | Slender | Blue | Light | Carbon, IN | Carbon | Farmer | None | ||||||
| Underwood | James Benjamin | 2 | Apr | 1882 | 36 | Short | Slender | Blue | Dark | US | Montezuma | Famer | E Underwood | ||||||
| Underwood | Ernest G | 2 | Apr | 1893 | 24 | Medium | Medium | Blue | Brown | Indiana | Indiana | Section Hand | Wife and 2 children | ||||||
| Underwood | John Franklin | 13 | Apr | 1890 | 27 | Tall | Slender | Blue | Black | Montezuma, IN | Montezuma | Famer | Wife and 2 children | ||||||
| Underwood | George Harrison | 28 | Jan | 1888 | 29 | Medium | Medium | Blue | Black | Armiesburg, IN | Montezuma | Famer | Wife and child | ||||||
| Upton | John Thomas | 12 | Sep | 1880 | 38 | Tall | Medium | Blue | Brown | US | Lena | Railroader | Jane Eaton | ||||||
| Uselman | Thomas Frederick | 3 | Apr | 1883 | 35 | Tall | Slender | Blue | Grey | US | Rockville | Paper Hanger | Cleo Duss uselman | ||||||
| Uselman | Scott | 21 | May | 1900 | 18 | Tall | Medium | Gray | L B | US | Rosedale | Famer | Louis Mann | ||||||
| Uselman | Clayton | 31 | Mar | 1873 | 45 | Medium | Medium | Blue | Light | US | Rosedale | Miner | Rosella Uselman | ||||||