Source: Zach, Karen Bazzani. Montgomery Medicine Men ... Crawfordsville: MCHS, 2002.
Found in the 1850 Franklin Township census, Dr. Warner is lsited as age 39 born in Vermont. His wife, Charity (whose maiden name may be Webster), was born there and was the same age. Son Hernon, age 13, was born in Michigan. Mary H, age 4, was born in Ohio while son, Jerome was one and born here. This family could not be found in the 1860 Indiana census so he evidently moved on.
Note: Since the above work was published, it is found that the Warners must have gone on to Astabula County, Ohio where Dr. Warner must have passed on. Harriet is found with her mother living with her (Charity Webster, age 74) and two of her children (Mary) Hilda age 14 and Jerome age 11.
They are still living in that township in the next census where Jerome is now with the circus as a "huckster". Harriet is 58 and her daughter, Mary Hilda is with her husband William House who is a sailor, age 35.