HISTORIES
OF THE
MONROE PRESBYTERIAN CHURCH
Beginning With
From The Centennial Handbook 1839 - 1939
Written by Mrs. Kathryn (Sarver) Bayless
Rev. & Mrs. D. C. Simpson - Pastor of the church for 25 years.
In order to understand the origin and history of Monroe Church we must learn of the founding of what rightfully is termed its
"parent chruch"
In the year 1816 there came from Dayton, Ohio, a man, Robert Elliott by name, a tanner by trade and a devout Presbyterian by religious belief.
He purchased from the government the quarter section of land lying directly south of this present church building, receiving for it a deed signed by President Madison
and written upon sheepskin.
Since there was no church in the immediate vicinity and feeling the need for a religious organization he decided to call a meeting at his house
to discuss the matter. The outcome of this meeting was the organization of a church on Sept. 25, 1830, first known as the Middlefork Presbyterian Church, and three
years later Presbytery changed its name to Lancaster Presbyterian Church. There was no church building but meetings were held around at various homes. In 1838 the
congregation built a huge log church on a part of Robert Elliott's farm. This structure was destroyed by fire in 1902, having been used as a dwelling after it ceased
to be used for church purposes.
The agitation caused by the "Abolition Movement" found its way into the Lancaster Church and under the date of June 22, 1839 the record states
that there was a division in the church and part of the membership adhered to the New School (Anti-Slavery) and part to the Old School (Pro-Slavery). It was then that the Monroe Presbyterian Church
was born, although for a time it went by the name of Lancaster Church N. S. The charter members consisted of nine of the younger men of the "Old Church" and their wives
as follows: Robert Elliott Jr., Catherine Elliott, Anthony L. Elliott, Elizabeth Elliott, John C. Salisbuty, Leah H. Salisbury, Miles W. Craig, Elizabeth Craig, Dr. Heil
Morrison, Anna S. Morrison, William McGee, Margaret McGee, Hezekiah Patton, Anne Patton, Daniel Baxter, Susan Baxter, John Nichols, Martha Nichols.
After five years of meeting at the homes and wherever opportunity afforded a place they determined to build them a church and the present stone
structure was the result. It was built in 1844 upon ground given by Mr. and Mrs. Anthony L. Elliott, from stone quarried by members of the congregation only a short
distance from the building site. The stone work was done by Mr. Nathan Yost, an expert stone mason and so much work and material were donated that the chuch was completed
with a cash outlay of less than $500.
During this time the parent church was still holding services in its log church one fourth mile distant but the slavery question being settled by the
Civil War, the two bodies decided to unite in hiring a minister who was to preach alternately in the two churches. After five years of this plan, on Sept 10, 1870 the
New Albany Presbytery appointed a committee to aid the two bodies in uniting the Lancaster Church joined with the Monroe Church and its list of elders and members was added
to that of Monroe. The name of Robert Elliott, Sr., founder and first elder of the original church headed that list, he then, being a man eighty-six years old.
In 1935 the church undertook its largest tsk in the field of expansion when it decided to build the Church Hall, a much needed building for social as
well as religious gatherings. The cornerstone for this structure was laid Aug. 15, 1935 and it was dedicated at a meeting of Presbytery in October, 1936, held at Monroe.
We are indeed proud of the fact that during it s one hundred years of existance the church has never been closed to services. Although there have
been periods when no regular minister served the church, there was always a Sabbath School in session the year around and supplied pastors at intervals. Although we can not
point to any remarkable achievements, as compared to some, however, we feel that the influence of this church in the community is not to be measured. Who knows what lives it
has been the means of changing. Let us strive to be faithful and loyal to the principles for which our church has always stood.
The following pastors have served the church: Rev. J. H. Johnson, 1840-1841; James Brown 1842; C. L. Bartlett, 1842-46; H. Curtis, 1846-47; A. A.
Vance, 1847-50; (died while pastor); J. M. Sadd, 1851-54; D. A. Bassett, 1854-58; Benjam'n Neal, 1859 (died after two months); Alexander Parker, 1862-66; Rev. C. McCain, 1870-72;
J. M. McRee, 1872-77; J. H. Brownson, 1879-80; J. D. Henning, 1881-82; aperiod of supplies from 1884- to 1897, many of them from Hanover students, names as follows: J. M. Beard,
Samuel Moffett, W. R. Brown, J. M. McRee, George Lamb, Dr. Barnard, W. B. Chamberlain, Thos. C. Moffett, M. M. Oldfather, Samuel Wilson; H. G. Pollock, 1897-99; J. H. Weaver, 1899-1904;
D. C. Simpson, 1904-1912; Vernon P. Martin, 1913-1915; O. L. Morgan, April to November, 1915; J. A. Gehrette, Dec. 1915 to June 1916; Henry M. Rogers, 1916-18; Lewellyn T. Lawrence,
1920-22; Daniel C. Simpson 1922-.
Following is the list of elders: Miles W. Craig, Hiel Morrison, John C. Salisbury, Thurstoon Wood, Robert Elliott, Jr., William McGee, Robert Elliott, Sr.,
James M. Elliott, Enos Wildman, John S. Salisbury, Alex V. Elliott, Jesse S. Green, Robert D. Chambers, Avery Jordan, Isaac Chambers, S. A. Elliott, John Shaw, David O. Monroe,
Chester Weatherford, Carl Paugh, Chester Murphy, Ransom Sarver, C. M. Elliott, Harry R. Barber.
The Author of this history Mrs. Katheryn (Sarver) Bayliss was born June 23, 1895, in Monroe Township, Jefferson County, the daughter of Ransom
and Frances Eva (Elliott) Sarver. She was a teacher in Monroe Township schools from 1912 to 1927. She was married to George W. Bayless March 18, 1922, in Jefferson County, and
they moved to Decatur County in 1941.
Katheryn (Sarver) Bayliss. High School Graduation, June 18, 1912, Dupont, Jefferson County, Indiana. From the Collection, of her Granddaughter Nancy Denny Barker.
>
From the George B Bayless Collection administered by Nancy Denny Barker, his Niece.
Another History of the Church
A Brief History of the Monroe Presbyterian Church
By Annie E. Allen
Published in "The Hoosier Genealogist, December 1998, pages 193-218, Volume 38, No. 4
The Monroe Presbyterian Church was a small country church established in Ridpath. Monroe Township, Jefferson County, Indiana. The church
grounds, as well as the surrounding farms, were purchased by the Federal Government to form the Jefferson Proving Ground in 1941. The church was located in Section 21 of Monroe Township.
The spiritual beginning, if not the actual beginning, of the Monroe Presbyterian Church started with the formation of the Middle Fork Presbyterian Church on
25 September 1830. The name was subsequently changed to the Lancaster Presbyterian Church. A few years later, the members (mirroring a national Presbyterian conflict) split into two
sides over the interpretation of the Westminster Confession, a cornerstone of the Presbyterian Church. Part of the church conflict was over slavery. The "Old Style" approach was more
conciliatory toward Southern Presbyterians, while the "New Stylers," including the founders of Monroe sided with the New England abolitionists. Though most of the congregates were
probably against slavery, they differed in the importance they assigned to its removal. Several of the "New Stylers" who would found Monroe, like Robert Elliott, Jr., were active
in the antislavery movement. Elliott drove a wagon for a meat-packing plant and also transported runaway slaves from Madison to his farm north of town, one stop on their way to freedom.
The division between the two groups was formalized on 22 June 1839, when the Old Style adherents wrote a statement of beliefs in the session book and appended their names. (This statement
was apparently excised from the book.) The session book records the names of members who would stay with the old church, and those who broke away to start a new one The Lancaster
Presbyterian Church, New Style, which eventually became the Monroe Presbyterian Church, once again taking the name from the township. The 1839 date was considered to be the founding
date for the new church. This group also kept the original session book begun in 1830.
The church struggled for a period, meeting in various homes before realizing that if they were going to grow, they needed a building. Anthony and Elizabeth
Elliott offered a lot from their farm on which to build the church. Nathan Yost was hired to dress the stone quarried from along Middle Fort Creek, and to direct the construction crew.
The church building was completed in 1844 costing less than $500 in cash.
br>
With the completion of the building, the church began to grow. After the Civil War, the natural affection of the separated families and neighbors led to the
reunion of the Lancaster and Monroe congregations in September 1870.
Monroe was kept as the name of the unified church. In the ensuing years, it grew with the small town, Ridpath, which developed around the church. The Monroe
Church Centennial was celebrated in August 1939. The final service was held on 16 February 1941, with the Reverend Daniel Simpson leading the worship. The church was a continuously
active force in the community for over the years and was an anchor and mainstay for generations of families in Monroe Township. Volume I of Sessional Records, transcribed below, is
in private hands.
Sessional Records of Monroe Presbyterian Church Monroe Township, Jefferson County Indiana Volume I
I have combined transcriptions by Miss Annie Allen, from two documents here, one a page done by Ruth Hoggatt with permission of the Indiana Historical Society and
the other done by an unknown author for Genealogy Trails.
Record of the congregation and proceedings of the Session of Middle Fork Church
Sep 24th 1830
On this day agreeably to previous appointment a four days meeting was commenced at Mr. Robert Elliot's with a view to the formation of a church and the administration of the Lord's
Supper.
On the 25th a church was organized, called the Middle Fork Church and consisting of the following members viz:
| Robert Elliot |
Charles M. Culbertson |
|
| Martha Elliot |
Rahamah Wilson |
David Loring |
| Elizabeth J. Craig |
Fanny Loring |
Jane M. Elliot |
| Miles W. Craig |
Sep 26th 1830
Added to the church by certificate
Ann Wells Elizabeth Patton
On examination
Jane Large Robert Kinnear
Sep 27th [1830]
Added by certifice [sic]
Mr. Hamilton Mrs. Hamilton
This 27th September a meeting of the newly constituted church was held and Robert Elliot and David Loring were duly elected elders; these person on the same day ordained to the office to
which they had been chosen.
James H. Johnston
In Madison Pby. at Jefferson church April 8th 1831.
Thus far examined and approved.
John M. Dickey Modr.
Sep 10th 1831
Session met at Robert Elliot's was constituted with prayer by Rev. J. H. Johnston.
The following persons were then examined and received into full communion with the church: viz:
| Mrs. Mary McGhee |
William McGhee |
Mary Ann McGhee |
| Mrs. Margaret Ann McGhee |
William Elliot |
Received the ordinance of baptism
Margaret Ann McGhee
Thus far examined by a committee at South Hanover and approved Sep 10th 1831.
May 14th 1831
Communion Season. Session met and was constituted by prayer, present Rev Jas. H. Johnston Modr, Robert Elliot and David Loring Eld.
Received by certificate Sarah Ann Thorn. On examination Anthony L. Elliot.
Concluded with prayer.
Thus far examined and approved in Madison Pby April 4th 1842
Samuel Gregg Mod
Aug 13 1832
Communion Season
Session met and was opened by prayer. Present Rev. John Parsons modr.
Robert Elliot and David Loring Elders,
The following persons were examined and received to the communion of the church viz.
Handy Tull
H.E. Patton Joseph Commiskee
Ann Patton Daniel Baxter
Mary C. Craig Susan Baxter
Enos Wildman B. Fenton
Isabella McGhee Miss Mary Large
Eliza Large Mrs. Jane Fenton
The following persons were baptized adults
Joseph Commiskee Mrs. Elizabeth Large
Mrs. Margaret Ann McGhee
Mrs. M. C. Craig, during the camp meeting on Rykers Ridge
Sep 1st 1832.
Three children were baptized viz.
William Craig of Miles W. Craig
Elizabeth, daughter of William H. Hamilton
William (?) - Son of Sarah Ann Thorn (not sure if child had middle initial)
Sep 9th 1832
Communion Season at South Hanover — the following persons were admitted into the church by examination
Samuel Wilson Robert Elliot, Junior
at the same time the following persons were baptized viz.
Mrs. Ann Patton Mr. B. Fenton
Mrs. Jane Fenton
Sep 23,1832
Session met in the school house and was moderated by Robert Elliot. The following persons on examination were admitted to the church
Miss Jane Large, Miss Martha Elliot. Concluded with prayer.
Octo 11th 1832
Preaching at the house of Samuel Wilson, by Rev Jas H. Johnston when household baptism was administer to the children viz..
Elizabeth N. Wilson Francis Roscius Wilson
Rahamah Wilson Adelaide Wilson
Nov 25. 1832.
Session met at the house of Mr. Elliot. Present Rev J. W. Cunningham and David Loring.
Constituted with prayer. Mrs. Mary Tull, wife of Handy Tull was admitted on examination to the communion of the church—Same day the
following persons were baptized
Adults Daniel Baxter Susan Baxter
Enos Wildman Mary Tull
Mary Large Jane Large
and Robert son of Anthony L. Elliot
Dec. 22. 1832
An election was held at the house of Mr. Robert Elliot for the purpose of choosing two additional ciders whereup Miles W. Craig and Samuel
Wilson were unanimously elected. Closed with prayer.
Jan 13. 1833.
Preaching at Robert Elliot's by Rev. Dr. Matthews, when at the same time, the two elders elect viz. Miles W. Craig and Samuel Wilson were
ordained to that office.
March 24 1833
Session of the church met present Robert Elliot David Loring Miles W. Craig and Samuel Wilson when it was mutually agreed for Samuel Wilson to
attend next Presbytery at South Hanover.
March 30th 1833
Samuel Wilson attended Presbytery as appointed. By the order of Presbytery the name of this church, was altered from Middle Fork to Lancaster
and will hereafter by known by the name of the Lancaster Presbyterian Church.
June 7th 1833
Preaching at the house of Bartholomew Fenton. when household baptism was administered by Rev. J. W. Cunningham to the following children viz.
Minerva Ann Elizabeth Jane
Jesse Lowry Josephine
James Campbell Bartholomew
Emily Willis
Mary John
Solomon
—All B. Fenton's family
June 7th 1833
Preaching at the house of William McGhee when the following infants were baptized, all the children of W. McGhee
Mary Jane Elizabeth Julia
Maria Louisa James Alfred
Isabel Adeline Margaret Ann
June 8th 1833.
Communion Season
Session met and was constituted by prayer. Present Rev. J. W. Cunningham, Robert Elliot. Miles W. Craig, David Loring, Samuel Wilson.
Received by certificate from Graham Church
Mrs. Jane Hood
On Examination Mrs. Mary W. Humphrey Closed by prayer.
June 9th 1833
Mrs. Mary W. Humphrey received the ordinance of baptism.
June 10th,1833.
Baptism administered to the following infants viz.
Lucretlia Ann daughter of Miles W. Craig
Emily Edick of Charles M. Culbertson
James Walter of Anthony L. Elliot
Cynthia Ann of David Loring
by the Rev. J. W. Cunningham
June 23rd 1833
Preaching at the house of Robert Kinnear, where household baptism was administered by the Rev. J. W. Cunningham to the following children viz.
James Harry Kinnear Isabella Kinnear Elizabeth Kinnear Margaret Kinnear
August 18th
Session met in the School House was constituted with prayer. Present
Rev. J. W. Cunningham
Robert Elliot Miles W. Craig
David Loring Samuel Wilson
When on examination Robert Graham and Nancy Graham were received into the church
Sep 1st 1833.
Preaching at Mr. Elliot's by Rev. J. W. Cunningham when the following infants were baptized.
Nowal - son of Robert and Nancy Graham
Sep 16th 1833
Camp meeting at Jefferson Church, where on examination
Ann Wilson was received into the church.
Sep 29. 1833
Communion Season
Session met and was constituted with prayer - Present Rev. J. W. Cunningham
Robert Elliot Miles W.Craig
David Loring Samuel Wilson
On examination Minerva Ann Fenton was received into the church.
Sep 30th 1833
Session met as on the day preaching and constituted by prayer, when on examination the following persons were received into the church viz
Rebecca Baxter, Elizabeth N. Wilson, Catharine Patton, Elizabeth Ann Beachboard
Oct 6th 1833
Preaching at the house of Daniel Baxter by Mr. J. W. Cunningham, when household baptism was administered to the following children viz.
Mary Jane Susan
John Nathaniel Sarah Ann
All H. E. Patton's family
Also Mary Martha Ann
Nathaniel Wilson Daniel
Children of Daniel Baxter
At the same time and place were likewise baptized
Rebecca Baxter Catharine Patton
Miles W. Craig attending Pby and likewise Synod as appointed.
Bartholomew Fenton departed this life Octo 11 1833.
Dec 26 1833
Session met this day — Present
Rev. J. H. Johnston
Robert Elliot Miles W. Craig
David Loring Samuel Wilson
Resolved unanimously that it is expedient to call a meeting of the church instanter[?] for the purpose of knowing what can be raised for the
support of Mr. Cunningham who has been our station supply for near two years last
Resolved the plan we are now about to pursue of calling on every individual name for (his purpose is the best we can adopt for the present,
showing at one view and with the least trouble, showing all brotherly and sisterly kindness one towards another, without ostentation, or a
pharisaical spirit, but with humility, meekness, and charity.
Knowing that the Lord loveth a cheerful giver
Resolved, as our names are called, we will answer according to our ability.
March 23, 1834
Resolved unanimously that David Loring attend next Pby.
In Madison Pby convened at Madison April 10th 1834 — Thus far examined and approved. John W. Cunningham Lancaster Church April 27.1834
Session met at Robert Elliot's constituted with prayer—members present Craig, Loring, Wilson, and Elliot—Samuel Wilson was unanimously chosen
Moderator of session Concluded with prayer. Robert Elliot Clk
Communion Season, May 16th 1834
Session met at Elliot's, constituted with prayer. All the members present. Moderated by Rev Samuel Gregg, S. T. Crawford was received from the
Delphi church to the communion of this church by letter. Concluded with prayer. Robert Elliot Clk.
May 17. 1834
Session met at the call of the Moderator. Present Wilson, Craig, Loring, and Elliot. Moderated by Rev. S. Gregg when the following persons were
received to the communion of the church by examination viz. Mrs. Jane Steele, Mr. Nathanial Robinson, and Martha his wife, Mr. John Nicholas and
Martha his wife. Concluded with prayer. Robert Elliot Clk
May 18th 1834
Session met as yesterday, opened with prayer. Rev. Mr. Gregg modr. Members present as on yesterday. Received by examination were
Julia Brisbane Nancy Johnston
Sarah Ann Mooney Elizabeth Jane Fenton
Closed with prayer. Robert Elliot Clk
Dec 22nd 1834.
Session met at the call of the Moderator—members present—Wilson, Craig and Elliot—when Samuel Wilson asked a letter of dismissal for himself, and
wife, and Ann and Elizabeth his daughters, from this church to become connected with the Second Church in Madison, and his request was granted.
Concluded with prayer.
Robert Elliot Clk
March 29th 1835
Session met at Elliot's. Brother Craig was appointed to attend the next stated meeting of Madison Presbytery to meet in Paris on the first Tuesday
in April.
Robert Elliot Clk
Thus far examined and approved in Madison Presbytery April 8, 1835
John Finey Crowe Modr
April 9th 1835
Owing to sickness in M Craig family. Elliot attended Pby as alternate.
Robert Elliot Clk.
June 20,1835
Communion season. Session met at the call of the moderator. Constituted with prayer by Rev. Samuel Gregg. Members present Loring, Craig, and Elliot.
Received by examination, James Culbertson, Miss Jane Patton, Miss Eliza Anne Barris, all in full communion in the church. Closed with prayer,
Robert Elliot, Clk.
April 17th 1836.
Session met at the call of the Moderator. Members present Loring, Craig, and Elliot, when William H. Hamilton asked a letter of dismission for himself
and wife from this church to become connected with the Jefferson church and his request was granted. Robert Elliot, Clk.
July 10th 1836.
Session met at the call of the Moderator. Present Loring Craig, Elliot when Samuel S. Crawford asked a letter of dismission, from this church to be
connected with the Logansport church, and his request was granted.
Robert Elliot, Clk.
Sep 3rd 1836
Session met at the call of the Moderator. Brother Loring was appointed to attend the next stated meeting of Madison Pby. to meet at Poplar Ridge church,
the last Thursday of September. Mr. Loring attended Pby as appointed.
Robert Elliot, Clk.
March 23 1837.
Session met at the call of the Moderator. Members present Rev. S. Salisbury, Craig, and Elliot. When Mrs. Martha Officer asked a letter of dismission
from this church, to be connected with the Smyrna church, and her request was granted. Brother Craig was appointed to attend the next slated meeting
of Madison Presbytery.
Robert Elliot, Clk.
April 6th 1837.
Presbyterian report of Lancaster church from April 1st 1836 to April 1 1837.
Number of members in communion by last report 53,br>
Dismissed 4
Total now in communion 49
Children baptized 8
For missions $7.57
Robert Elliot. Clk.
In Madison Presbytery, April 8, 1837 this far examined and approved.
John M. Dickey, Moderator
April 8,1837.
Communion Season. Session met; opened with prayer. Present Rev. Daniel Latimore, Loring, Craig, and Elliot, when Mrs. Martha Elliot and Mrs. Sarah Salisbury
were received into the church by letter. Closed with prayer.
Robert Elliot, Clk.
June 12th 1837.
Session met. Opened with prayer when David Loring asked for a letter of dismission for himself and wife, and his request was granted.
Robert Elliot. Clk.
Sep 9 1837
Communion season. Session met opened with prayer. Members present Rev. John F. Crowe, Craig, and Elliot, when John C. Salisbury and Nancy Davis, presented
letters and was received in full communion in the church. Closed with prayer.
Robert Elliot, Clk.
Oct. 2nd 1837.
Session met. and was opened with prayer. Present R. James H. Johnston, Craig, and Elliot. Mr. John Hood appeared before session and stated that he had been
recently censured as he had been informed for contumacy by the session of Jefferson church: for refusing to submit to their authority, and he further stated
that this refusal was based on the supposition that his membership was at present, and had been for more than four years, in the Lancaster church, and he
therefore, wished to be informed, by this session whether his supposition was correct. Where upon it was resolved, that this session recognize Mr. Hood as
a member of Lancaster Church; and they further state that they so regarded him for the length of time above specified. The session deem it their duty to
insert on their records the following statements. viz: It is within the distinct recollection of both members of this session, that at a meeting of the
session held June 8th 1833 at which Rev. Samuel Gregg, then Pastor of Jefferson Church, was present and at which the wife of Mr. Hood was received into the
church, Mr. Hood himself made application for admission, Mr. Gregg testified verbally to Mr. Hood's good standing in the Jefferson Church, and assented to
his transfer to Lancaster church, and this session regarded Mr. Hood as having according been received, at that time, as a member of this church. It is owing
in their opinion, purely to the omission by the clerk of the session, that his name was not recorded on our minutes. Closed with prayer.
Robert Elliot, Clk.
Oct. 2nd 1838.
Session met, when Mrs. Julia Bais Lane, asked a letter of dismission from Lancaster church to join the first church in Madison and her request was granted.
Robert Elliot. Clk.
April 1st 1838.
Presbyterian report of Lancaster Church
from April 1st 1837 to April 1st 1838.
Number of members in communion
At last report 49
Dismissed by letter 3
Received by letter 4
Total now in communion 50
Infants baptised 4
Robert Elliot, Clk.
In Madison Pby April 13th 1838. Thus far examined and approved. William C. Matthews, Modr.
Lancaster Church 23rd June 1838.
Session met at the call of the Moderator. Present Rev. Daniel Latimore, Craig I Mint, with prayer. A letter ot dismission was granted to Mis. Nancy Davis to
join the Vernon church. The following members were received by letter, viz. Dr. H. Morrison and Anna S. Morrison his wife and Mrs. Leah S. Salisbury.
Mr. John Hood, a member of this church came before session and state that common fame charged him with unchristian conduct as having aided and abetted in a horse race
by holding and paying over the stakes to the winner. He said his motive was that he might be a competent witness in the case; but as the act had given offence to his
brethren, and given the enemy cause to speak reproachfully, he deeply regretted having done so and would not under similar circumstances do so again. Whereupon it was
resolved that his statements and acknowledgment be considered satisfactory to the session and be published tomorrow to the congregation. Concluded with prayer, Robert
Elliot, C. S.
Sep 15, 1838.
Agreebly to a previous notice, an election was held in the Lancaster church, for the purpose of choosing one additional elder, whereupon. Dr. H. Morrison was elected
and ordained to that office by Doctor Matthews.
Robert Elliot, C. S.
Sep — 1838
Mrs. Ann Wells - Mrs. Mary Tull and Mrs. Eliza Ann Wright, all dismissed themselves by joining the Baptist church. Robt Elliot, C. S.
Oct 28th 1838
Session of Lancaster church met. Present Rev. J. H. Johnston Modr., Miles W. Craig, and Dr. H. Morrison elders. By request Mrs. Sarah Salisbury was dismissed to join
the second church of Madison.
Received to communion of the church John Campbell, on a certificate from the First Congregational Church in Lebanon, New York.
Dr. H. Morrison was appointed to attend Pby in Madison, next Oct., 31st.
Dec; 1st 1838
Church of Lancaster, employed Rev A. S. Morrison to labor among them for one year.
H. Morrison, Clk.
Madison Pby in session approved lo this date March 30. 1839.
James Blythe Modr.
June 22,1839.
The following preamble and resolution were drawn up as a new Test of church membership by the Old School portion of the church. In as much as it is desirable that every
one's standing in the church be known, and whereas it is desirable, both to us and to the Pby of Madison, to know who compose the Lancaster church, therefore Resolved
that we whose names are hereunto set, declare our adherence to Madison Pby and through it to the General Assembly which met and held its sessions in the 7th Presbyterian
Church in Philadelphia in May 1838.
To this were appended the following names:
Robert Elliot Martha Elliot
Enos Wildman Jane Wildman
Sarah Ann Thorne Elizabeth Fenton
William Elliot Minerva Ann Elliot
Mary Humphrey Charles M. Culbertson
John Hood Jane Hood
Robert Graham Nancy Graham
Alexander Caldwell Rebecca Caldwell
Nathaniel Rowlison Jane Rowlison
Elizabeth A. Beachboard Sarah Johnston
Henry Thorne Jane Fenton
Whereupon the above members retired from the communion of our church and became a separate organization.
[At this point in the Session Book, one page has been entirely removed, as well as the top two inches of the succeeding page.)
Text begins again at this point:
May 19th 1839
Baptised Sarah Elizabeth, daughter of Hiel and Anna S. Morrison
H. Morrison, Clk.
June 30,1839 Communion
Received on certificate Dennis L. Freeman, Isabella Loring, Elizabeth Craig
On Examination Mary Baxter;
H. Morrison. Clk.
June 20th 1839
Baptized infants of John C. and Leah Salisbury - infant Mary Stoddard
[Top two inches of page is missing)
Text begins again at this point
of Anthony L. and Elizabeth Elliot - Elisabeth Emmina
of Robert and Catharine Elliott - Mary Ann
of Rebecca Cummiskee - Daniel. Andrew S. Morrison
Aug 1839
Preaching at the house of Mr. John Nichols and baptized two children of said J. Nichols. Andrew S. Morrison, Modr.
Sep 1839
Preaching at William McGhee's when two of his children were baptized. Andrew S. Morrison. Modr.
1840 Jan 1st
Lancaster Church employed Rev. J. H. Johnson to preach near half the Sabbath for one year. H. Morrison, Clk.
Aug 1st 1840 Communion
Rec'd on certificate Edwin S. Morrison. Alfred A. Morrison and Nancy his wife.
On examination and baptized, Eveline Morrison and Agnes Mowrer.
H. Morrison, Clk
Feb 13,1841
The Session of Lancaster Church met Feb. 13 1841. Present Rev J. H. Johnson Mod. Miles W. Craig and Hiel Morrison. Elders resolved that a meeting of the members of the Lancaster
Church be call to be held on Saturday the 6th day of March next at 2 o'clock P. M. for the purpose of electing one or more additional elders.
Resolved that Hiel Morrison and Mrs. Anna S. Morrison his wife be dismissed from this church and recommended to the 2nd Church in Madison. Adjourned.
1841 March 6th
According to a previous appointment or notice an election was held for the purpose of choosing one or more additional elders, whereupon John C. Salisbury was elected to that office,
and was ordained elder of Lancaster Church by Revd Henry Little. Miles W. Craig, Clk.
May 1841
Baptised James Thompson, son of John C. and Leah Salisbury.
September 1841
Hiel Morrison and Anna S. his wife received by certificate.
Deceased Mrs. Mary Whitson Sep 26th 1841. H. Morrison, Clk.
Oct 1841
Mr. James Brownlee became staled supply
Apr 1842
Mr. James Brownlee ordained Pastor of this and Central Church.
H. Morrison, Clk.
Martha A. McDonough received on examination. Sep 1842 Dismissed by letter.
H. Morrison, Clk.
May 22nd 1842
Session met constituted with prayer. Revd James Brownlce Moderator.
M. W. Craig, J. Salisbury, and H. Morrison elders.
Resolved that Alfred A. Morrison and Nancy his wife be at their own request dismissed to be connected with a church more contiguous to them. Resolved
that H. Morrrison, as clerk of session be authorized to forward said dismission, which was accordingly done. Adjourned with prayer.
H. Morrison. Clk.
Oct 8th 1842
Received on examination: Thurston Wood and Hannah his wife.
H. Morrison. Clk.
Oct 22nd 1842
Recd on examination John Kirkwood and Eliza Jane Palcrson
Recd on examination two Miss McGhees, Margaret and Louisa, daughters of William McGhee.
Oct 1842
Sarah Ann Kyle (before marriage, Mooney) dismissed at her own request. H. Morrison, Clk.
May 7th 1843
Dismissed by certificate, Eliza J. Patcrson and John Campbell to join Second Presbyterian Church in Madison. H. Morrison, Clk.
July 9th 1843
Baptized by Revd J. M. Dickey:
John Simean, son of John and Leah Salisbury.
James Hezekiah, son of Robert and Catharine Elliott.
Ann Matilda, daughter of Mrs. Rebecca Cummiskee.
July 9th 1843
Session met
Resolved that Mrs. Mary Chambers has been charged, by public fame; with having violated the laws of chastity (having had an issue within four or five months after marriage)
within the past year. Session regard it as their duly, for the honor of the church and the cause of Christ, that the matter should be properly disposed of. Therefore,
resolved that a committee be appointed by session to converse with her in relation lo the charge, and more especially, lo learn her views of humility, and repentance,
before God for the wrong done. A committee was accordingly appointed for that purpose. Session adjourned.
July 25th 1843
Session met. The committee having visited Mrs. Chambers, and she having made satisfactory acknowledgments, and expressions of repentance, and sorrow for the evil done.
Therefore session resolve that she be now regarded as being in regular standing in the church, and is recommended to the confidence and fellowship of the church. Session
adjourned.
The above decision was read in the Church September 3rd 1843.
H. Morrison, Clk.
Feb 25th 1844
Baptized Simean Salisbury, son of Anthony L. and Elizabeth Elliott H. Morrison, Clk.
List of names of the members of Lancaster Church March 25th 1844
John Salisbury to Leah Salisbury
Miles W. Craig to Mary Craig
Anthony L. Elliott to Elizabeth Elliott
Robert Elliott, Jr. to Catherine Elliott
Hezekiah E. Patton to Anna Patton
Daniel Baxter to Susan Baxter
William McGhee to Margaret McGhee
Hiel Morrison to Anna S. Morrison
Widow Jane Large Miss Mary Jane McGhee
Mrs. Agnes Mowerrer Louisa McGhee
Jane (Patton now Mrs. Chambers) William Whitson
Mary Baxter (now Mrs. Chambers) Thurston Wood
John Nichols Mrs. Hannah Wood
Mrs. Martha Nichols John Kirkwood
Elizabeth (widow) Craig Mrs. Rebecca Cummiskee
Mrs. McGhee (widow) Edwin S. Morrison
Isabella Loring Mrs. Eveline Morrison
Mary Ann Banes Handy Tull (dismissed)
In Madison Presbytery at Vevay Apr 5 1844 thus far examined and approved with the exception that Presbytery recommend that a list of Baptisms be kept separate from the records
of the session.
S. R. Booth, Moderator
April 23, 1844
Samuel Thornton and George Washington, Children of William and Margaret A. McGee were baptised by Rev. C. L. Bartlett. Also Sydney Caroline, infant daughter of Hiel and Anna
S. Morrison.
Monroe Church Oct 3 1844.
Session met in the meeting house. Present C. L Bartletl Moderator; Miles W. Craig, Hiel Morrison and John Salisbury, Elders. Constituted with prayer. Received by letter.
Emmeline D. Bartlett. Closed with prayer.
Oct 6,1844
Mary Eriminah, infant daughter of Charles L. and Emmeline D. Bartlett, was baptized by the Rev. W. A. Smith. Also by the same, Elisa Catherine, infant daughter of Daniel and
Susan Baxter.
Oct 7,1844
According to previous appointment, the Monroe Church met in the meeting house for the purpose of electing an additional Elder. On counting the votes, it was found that Thurston
Wood was duly elected. After session, Mr. Wood, having signified his willingness to accept the appointment, and having answered the Constitutional questions, was ordained to the
office of Ruling Elder, by the Rev. C. L. Bartlett.
Madison Presbytery April 7 1845 Thus far examined and approved.
John M. Dickey. Modr.
[only sentence on page):Dr. Haines dismissed by letter.
April 12, 1845
Session met in the meeting house. Present C. L. Bartlett, Moderator; Miles W. Craig, Hiel Morrison, John Salisbury, and Thurston Woods, Elders.
Constituted with prayer.
Received by letter Mr. William O. Rockwood and Mrs. Hellen M. Rockwood, his wife, and also Dr. A. B. Haines and by examination Miss Susan Tull, Catherine Ryker, and Walter Elliott.
Closed with prayer.
Sept 13,1845
Session met in the meeting house, Present C. L. Bartlett, Moderator; John C. Salisbury and Miles W. Craig Elders. Constituted with prayer. Received on examination Elizabeth McGee.
Closed with prayer.
April 1st 1846 Triennial Report of Monroe Presbyterian Church to Presbytery.
Total number members at last report 47
Received on examination 4
Received by letter 4_8
55
Dismissed and Removed _21
Total in Communion 34
Baptisms
Adults 00
Infants 12 Total 12
Commissioners Fund $4.07
Contingent
Foreign Missions 5.00
Home Missions 14.00
Bible Society 0.00
Education paid by C. L. Bartlett 10.00
Other Objects ($300 Church Bible $10 S.S.U.)
310.00
Total $343.07
Madison Presbytery April 33, 1846 The records thus far examined and approved. H. Curtis, Modr.
June 14th 1846
Baptised by Revd C. L. Bartlett, Sarah Abigail, Daughter of John C. and Leah Salisbury.
The Stated Supplies of Revd C. L. Bartlett terminated June 15th 1846 (in the Monroe Church).
Dec 14th 1846
Baptised by Revd H. Curtis, David Nelson, son of H. and Anna S. Morrison.
Jan 1 1847
Dismissed by letter William O. Rockwood and Hellen M., his wife, to join the Second Presbyterian Church in Madison, Indiana. H. Morrison, Clk. of Session
Lawrenceburg, April 14,1847 The preceding records have been examined and approved. The Presbytry would however, direct the session to have entered in the book a distinct mention
of the change of the name of the church and also a full list of the names of the members.
B. H. Morris, Modr.
Monroe June 1817
Session met at the church and received upon examination Mr. Wilson Morrison and Mrs. Matilda Hamilton. Session closed with prayer.
Monroe, Sept 1st 1847
Session met at campground near Monroe Church. Present Miles Craig, J. C. Salisbury, and Hiel Morrison. Rev. H. Curtis Moderator. The following persons were examined and received
to membership in Monroe Church: Harden Wetherford. William C. Ryker, Amos Stark, John Stark, Eliza Stark, Sarah Stark. Mary L. Fenton, Sarah Ann Patton, Juliann Wetherford,
Elizabeth Patton. The names following reed to b... church: Saml P. Salyers, Susanna Salyers, and Jacob Gobbott
Monroe Sept 5th 1847
Session met after Morning Service. Present: Miles Craig, J. C. Salisbury. The following persons were received upon examination: Miss Margaret McGhee. Mrs. Elizabeth Roberts. William
Craig, Saml Wood. John Patton. William Thomas.
Monroe Oct 3rd 1847
Session met constituted with prayer. Present M. Craig and J. C. Salisbury.
Miss Elizabeth Hudson was examined and received to membership in the church.
Monroe Oct 17th 1847
Session met constituted with prayer. Present M.Craig and J. C.Salisbury. The following persons were examined and received to membership in the church, viz.
Miss Elizabeth Chambers, Miss Charlotte Craig, Miss Catharine Craig, Miss Jane Stark presented a letter from Lancaster Church and Mrs. C. A. Vance from Fulton, Ohio. Both received.
Monroe Nov 14th 1847
Session Constituted by prayer. Present M. Craig, J. C. Salisbury. Rev. A. A.
Vance Mod. Mr. John Chambers was examined and received to membership...
Aurora April 5, 1848
Thus far examined and approved. S. Kelsey, Modr.
July 23rd 1848
According to previous appointments the members of Monroe Church met for the purpose of electing two additional elders. Upon counting the votes, it was ascertained that Robert Elliott
and William McGee were elected to fill these stations. [Note: The Robert Elliott elected as elder at this time was the son of the Robert Elliot of earlier entries. He was commonly
known as Robert Elliott, Jr.]
Aug 20 1848
Robert Elliott and William McGee were ordained elders in Monroe Church by A. A. Vance, pastor. A. A. Vance, Clk.
Aug 30th 1848
Session met at Monroe Campground and the moderator and members all being present. Session constituted with prayer. The following persons were examined and received into membership:
Elizabeth H. Calloway, Mary Ann Craig. Emily Craig, Rebecca Corbin, George Myers, Elizabeth Myers, Sidney Peterson, Sarah Manning, Leah Woodfill.
Aug 31st 1848
Session met at Monroe Campground. Present Craig, Salisbury, Elliott, and McGee. A. A. Vance Modr. Session constituted with prayer. The following persons were examined and received to
membership in Monroe Church, viz. Jacob Calloway, William Craig, Mrs. Richmond, Edwin Manning, Gregg Woodfill and John Craig. A. A. Vance, Clk.
Sept 2nd 1848
Session met at Hoppers School house. Present all the members, opened with prayer. The following individual was examined and received to membership in Monroe Church, viz. James Woods.
A. A. Vance, Clk.
Monroe Sept 17th 1848
Session met at church. All the members present. Opened with prayer. That Oliver H. Hamilton after deliberate and careful examination was received to membership in this church. A. A.
Vance, Clk
Sept 31st 1848
Session met at church. All the member present. Opened with prayer. John Caldwell was received to membership after a careful examination. Letters were also received from Andrew
Woodfill, Mary S. Woodfill and Martha J. Woodfill and they were received into the communion of this church.
A. A. Vance, Clk.
General Report of Monroe Church from Apr 1 1846 to Apr 1 1849
Total Members at last report 34
Added by letter 5
Added by examination 36
75
Dismissed by letter 8
Died 1
9
Total in Communion 66
Baptisms
Adult 5
Infants 10
Rising Sun April 4th 1849. Thus far examined by Presbytery and Approved J. M. Dickey, Moderator of Presbytery Monroe
June 23rd 1849
Session met constituted with prayer. All the members present. After a full conversation on the state of the church no other business being presented, the Session adjourned. A. A. Vance. Clk.
Sept 3rd 1849
Session met at Hoppers Schoolhouse and was constituted with prayer, all the members present. After a full and careful examination, the following persons were received to membership in
this church: Julia Ann Nicols, Amanda Nicols, Francis Nicols. Mary Ann Elliott. Elizabeth Craig, Mary Jane Weatherford, Harriet McGee, Louisa Hamilton. George Seal.
Mr. William McGee was appointed to represent this church at Presbytery and Mr. R. Elliott al Synod with M. W. Craig alternate. A. A. Vance, Clk.
Monroe Oct 28th 1849
Session met. was constituted with prayer. All the members present. After a careful examination, the following persons were received to the communion of the church. Mary Delass, Elizabeth
Elliott. Adjourned.
A. A. Vance. Clk.
Monroe Feb. 17th 1850
Session met and was constituted with prayer. All the members present. After a careful examination, Mr. Robert Huey was received into the communion of this church. Adjourned. A. A. Vance, Clk.
Monroe March 17th 1850
Session met; constituted with prayer. All the members being present. Mr John C. Salisbury was appointed to represent this church in Presbytery and Robert Elliott alternate. A. A. Vance, Clk.
Statistical Report from Apr 1st 1849 to April 1st 1850
Total in last report 66
Added by examination 13
79
Died 1
Baptisms Adults 4
Infants 2
A. A. Vance, Clk.
Vevay April 3rd 1850. The within records thus far examined and approved. L. R. Booth, Mod.
Monroe June 8th 1850
A meeting of the congregation was held at the meeting house after preaching where it was unanimously resolved that the church do earnestly desire and do now request Brother Thurston Wood
to become an acting elder in this church. Bro. Wood in a most appropriate address, expressed his willingness to serve God and the church in this or any way that may serve best.
June 9th 1850
Session met, was constituted with prayer. Present Salisbury, Craig, McGee, Wood, and Elliott. Misses Susan and Sarah Kanier were examined and received to the communion of this church. A. A. Vance, Clk.
June 23,1850
Session met. Was constituted with prayer. Rev. A. A. Vance presided—present, Bros. Salisbury, Craig, Wood, and Elliott. Mr. John L. Kinnear and Elisabeth his wife were examined and received
into the church. Thurston Wood, Clk.
Monroe Nov 6th 1850
The Rev. A. A. Vance, after a lingering sickness of more than six months, departed this life, much lamented by all who knew him.
Thus far examined and approved. Allensville, April 2, 1851
B. F. Morris, Modr.
The Session Record is continued in new book.
List of Members in Monroe Presbyterian
MALE
| Miles W.Craig |
Dr. Hiel Morrison (Dismissed to Tabernacle Church cir Nov. 20. 1847) |
John C. Salisbury |
| Thurston Wood |
Anthony Elliott |
Robert Elliott, Jr. |
| William McGee |
Daniel Baxter |
John Nicols |
| Hezekiah E. Patton (Dismissed) |
William Whitson |
Walter Elliott |
FEMALE
| Mrs. Elizabeth Craig |
Anna S. Morrison |
Leah H. Salisbury |
| Hannah Wood |
Elizabeth Elliott |
Catharine Elliott |
| Margaret McGee |
Susan Baxter |
Martha Nicols |
| Patton (dead) |
Agnes Mowrcr |
Isabella Loring |
| Rebecca Cummiskee |
Mary Chambers |
Miss Susan Tull |
| Miss Catharine Ryker |
Miss Mary Jane McGee |
Miss Ijwi.sa McGee |
Miss Elizabeth McGee |
The above are the names of all the members to this date now in communion List of Members in Monroe Church
The following list is of people who became members subsequent to the date of the previous listing.
NAMES
| Dr Wilson Morrison |
Mrs. Matilda Hamilton |
Harden Wetherford |
| William C. Ryker |
Amos Stark |
John Stark |
| Eliza Stark |
Sarah Stark |
|
| Mary L. Fenton |
Sarah Ann Patton |
Julianne Wetherford |
| Elizabeth Patton |
Margaret McGee |
Mrs. Elizabeth Roberts |
| Samuel Woods |
William Craig |
John Patton |
| William Thomas |
Elizabeth Hudson |
Miss Elizabeth Chambers |
| Miss Charlotte Craig |
Miss Catharine Craig |
Miss Jane Stark |
| Mrs. C. A. Vance |
Mrs. John Chambers |
Elizabeth Calloway |
| Mary Ann Craig |
Emily Craig |
Rebecca Corbin |
| George Myers |
Mrs. Elizabeth Myers |
Sidney Peterson |
| Sarah Manning |
Leah Woodfill |
Jacob Calloway |
| William Craig |
Edwin Manning |
Mrs. Richmond, Madison |
| Gregg Woodfill |
John Craig, N. Madison |
Mrs. Lindley |
| Mrs. Patton |
STUDENT
| Oliver H. Hamilton |
Dr. John Coldwell |
Andrew Woodfill |
| Mary S. Woodfill |
Martha J. Woodfill |
Julia Ann Nicols |
| Amanda Nicols |
Francis Nicols |
Martha Nicols |
| Mary Ann Elliott |
Elizabeth Craig |
Mary Jane Weatherford |
| Louisa Hamilton |
George Seal |
Mary Delass |
| Elizabeth Elliott |
Robert Huey |
Miss Sarah Kanier |
| Miss Susan Kanier |
John L. (?) Kinnear |
Elizabeth Kinnear |
| Julianne Wetherford Sept 1, 1847 |
William Thomas Oct 28, 1847 |
Elizabeth Chambers Oct 28, 1847 |
| Elizabeth Myers Aug 30, 1848 |
Francis Nicols Sept 9, 1849 |
George Seal Sept 9, 1849 |
| Elizabeth Craig Oct 28, 1849 |
Mary Delass Oct 28, 1849 |
A A & C A Vance Little June 9. 1850 |
| R & C Elliott Vance June 9, 1850 |
Walter Roberts Oct 28, 1847 |
John Robert Elliott April 14, 1845 |
| Hellen Marr Rockwood April 14, 1845 |
Mary Jane Elliott March 21, 1846 |
Sarah Abigail Salisbury June 14, 1846 |
| William Manning Sept 14, 1847 |
Robert McGhee Sept 14, 1847 |
James H. Vance Sept 14, 1847 |
| Alexander Vance Elliott Oct 28. 1847 |
John Roberts Oct 28, 1847 |
Edwin Roberts Oct 28, 1847 |
| Jarad Vance Salisbury May 28, 1848 |
Susan Lauretta Elliott May 28, 1848 |
Cummisky Oct 28, 1848 |
| David McClure Elliott Oct 28, 1848 |
Sophia Elizabeth Vance June 9, 1850 |
Sarah Catharine Elliott June 9, 1850 |
Monroe Presbyterian (Monroe Twp., Jefferson Co.)
Written by Robert W. Scott
The Monroe Presbyterian Church was originally known as the Middle Fork Presbyterian Church, which formed on Sept. 25, 1830 in a meeting at the
home of Robert Elliott. The meeting actually began on Sept. 24. The name was changed to Lancaster Presbyterian Church on March 30, 1833. The name
originated from the fact that what became Monroe Township was then part of Lancaster Township.
A 1939 church history lists as Robert Elliott Jr., Catherine Elliott, Anthony L. Elliott, Elizabeth Elliott, John C. Salisbury, Leah H. Salisbury,
Miles W. Craig, Elizabeth Craig, Dr. H. Morrison, Anna S. Morrison, William McGee, Margaret McGee, Hezekiah Patton, Anne Patton, Daniel Baxter, Susan Nichols and Martha
Nichols. This list is not in agreement with the list dated Sept. 25 that lists only Robert and Martha Elliott, David and Fanny Loring, Miles W. and Elizabeth Craig, Charles
M. Culbertson, Rahamah Wilson, and Jane M. Elliot. The 1939 list, compiled by Katherine Bayless, apparently reflects those members remaining with Lancaster/Monroe after the
Old Style members withdrew their membership.
According to a history by Anne E. Allen (1998), who transcribed session minutes covering the period from the church's founding until 1850, the church
was split between the Old Style Presbyterians and New Style. The groups split over the interpretation of the Westminster Confession with the Old Style members being more
sympathetic to Southern Presbyterians and the New Stylers favoring New England abolitionists. On June 22,1839, the Old Style believers wrote a statement of belief in the
session book. This statement was excised from the record. This is the date from which Monroe counted its formation. (Monroe Township was formed from part of Lancaster
Township, hence the original church name.) Session minutes show that the church was still known as Lancaster Church on March 25, 1844, but had changed its name to Monroe
by Oct. 7, 1844.
Land in Section 21 Twp. 5N Range 10E was deeded to Alexander Caldwell, William Elliott and Henry Thorne, trustees of the Lancaster Presbyterian
Church by Robert Elliott on May 29, 1840 (Jefferson Co. Deed Book S p. 170.) In another deed dated April 27, 1849, land was deeded by Robert Elliott Jr. Miles W. Craig,
Anthony Elliott, J.C. Salisbury and Thurston Wood to John C. Salisbury, Thurston Wood, and Robert Elliott, trustees for Monroe. A stone church was completed in 1844. After
the Civil War, the old and new church reconciled, with both bodies meeting in the same building from 1865 to 1870 and finally reuniting in 1870. A stone building was
completed in 1935 but the church closed on Feb. 2, 1941 as the church property was taken over as part of the Jefferson Proving Ground. Some of its membership combined
with the Smyrna Presbyterian Congregation.
You may use this material for your own personal research, however it may not be used for commercial publications without express written consent of the contributor, INGenWeb, and Sheila Kell
.jpg)
