New Mount Pleasant Cemetery
New Mount Pleasant Cemetery is located near the intersection
of Mount Pleasant & Como Roads, down a lane in a wooded area near Red
Key in Jefferson Township.
The current listing is taken from the information on the previous
Jay Co Burials page, county histories, tombstone photographs, funeral home records and obituaries.
If you know the history of the cemetery or have an obit or tombstone photo you are willing to share, please contact Jim Cox.
Surnames that are capitolized have a biography attached. Click on the FIRST name to read the bio.
M/M = Mr and Mrs; * = birth date calculated on age at death
BHFHR = Baird-Hardy Funeral Home Records
The current listing is taken from the information on the previous
Jay Co Burials page, county histories, tombstone photographs, funeral home records and obituaries.
If you know the history of the cemetery or have an obit or tombstone photo you are willing to share, please contact Jim Cox.
Surnames that are capitolized have a biography attached. Click on the FIRST name to read the bio.
M/M = Mr and Mrs; * = birth date calculated on age at death
BHFHR = Baird-Hardy Funeral Home Records
Updated 9/21/2020
|
New Mount Pleasant Cemetery
|
||||||||
| Last Name | First Name (Maiden) | Birth Date | Death Date | Spouse Marriage Date |
Parents | Military | Obit | Stone |
| Bair | Catherine (Bloom) | 10-5-1818 | 12-29-1894 | Samuel T | ||||
| Bair | David | 6-16-1863 | 8-12-1864 | Samuel T & Catherine Bloom Bair | ||||
| Bair | Elizabeth Ellen (McCartney) | 3-26-1868 | 4-4-1888 | Edward M - 6/13/1885 | Thomas & Hettie Bost McCartney | |||
| Bair | Samuel T | 6-8-1817 | 2-6-1877 | Catherine Bloom | ||||
| Barnes | Caroline (Nixon) | 6-14-1847 | 6-1-1897 | Isaac | ||||
| Barnes | Isaac | 8-15-1842 | 12-17-1886 | Caroline Nixon | Civil War Co H 75th Ind Inf | |||
| Bell | Alva | 1-20-1851 | 7-20-1854 | John & Levina | ||||
| Bell | John | 9-6-1816* | 1-21-1880 | Lovina Kidder | Dr Simeon & Mary West Bell | Bio | ||
| Bell | Levina (Kidder) | 4-10-1821 | 1-22-1899 | John | John & Sarah Burns Kidder | |||
| Bell | Mary | 11-14-1852 | 7-14-1854 | John & Levina | ||||
| Bell | Rosanna | 3-22-1849 | 7-22-1854 | John & Levina | ||||
| Bell | Sarah | 11-30-1846 | 7-31-1854 | John & Levina | ||||
| Bell | William Finley | 2-15-1845 | 10-4-1911 | John & Lavina Kidder Bell | BHFHR | |||
| Bost | James O | 1863 | 1876 | |||||
| Brewster | Nancy (Dailey) | 7-22-1838 | 2-3-1850 | Watson | Nathaniel & Siddy Dailey | |||
| Brewster | Watson | 8-19-1833 | 6-12-1858 | |||||
| Brubaker | Abraham | 1854 | 1937 | Benjamin & Harriet A Butt Brubaker | ||||
| Brubaker | Alva E | 4-1-1878 | 1-23-1901 | obit | ||||
| Brubaker | Benjamin | 1-1-1813 | 1876 | Harriet A Butt - 1836; Elsie Fowler - 1858 | Abraham & Elizabeth Flora Brubaker | |||
| Brubaker | Benjamin | 1852 | 1938 | Benjamin & Harriet A Butt Brubaker | ||||
| Brubaker | Dorcia D | 1-12-1869 | J & S F | |||||
| Brubaker | Elmer | 1865 | 1944 | s/s Etta | ||||
| Brubaker | Elsie (Fowler) | 1830 | 1912 | Benjamin | ||||
| Brubaker | Etta | 1868 | 1947 | s/s Elmer | ||||
| Brubaker | Gabriel H | 1870 | 1899 | Benjamin & Elsie Fowler Brubaker | ||||
| Brubaker | John Elmer | 1864 | 1944 | Benjamin & Elsie Fowler Brubaker | ||||
| Brubaker | Jonathan Robert | 5-19-1840 | 4-25-1926 | Sarah E Mundhench; Manerva Counterman | Benjamin & Harriet A Butt Brubaker | |||
| Brubaker | Manerva (Counterman) | 12-3-1865 | 7-2-1886 | Jonathan R | ||||
| Brubaker | Mary Ann | 1858 | 1939 | |||||
| Brubaker | Sarah E (Mundhench) | 6-19-1850 | 11-13-1883 | Jonathan R - 6/10/1866 | ||||
| Byrd | infant | abt 1-0-1903 | 9-22-1903 | death notice | ||||
| Carpenter | Emily | 1-13-1848 | 4-4-1860 | |||||
| Carpenter | William | 3-5-1810 | 10-15-1871 | |||||
| Corwin | Charles | 2-3-1873 | 6-3-1874 | S & C | ||||
| Corwin | Jonathan | 5-8-1869 | 6-8-1869 | S & C | ||||
| Coulson | Jabez G | 5-9-1841 | 10-4-1907 | Co F 140th IN Inf | ||||
| Coulson | Sarah M | 10-9-1841 | 12-19-1876 | Jabez G | ||||
| Coulson | Sarah N | 2-29-1832 | 10-4-1888 | Jabez G | ||||
| Coulson | William A | 9-15-1864 | 9-4-1895 | Jabez G | ||||
| Coulson-Tinkle | Sarah | 6-14-1822 | 7-28-1905 | Jabez Coulson; Jacob Tinkle | obit | |||
| Craig | Amelia Jane (Graves) | 4-27-1847 | 4-30-1929 | Price K | Layton I Graves | |||
| Craig | Anna | 1-16-1884 | 5-21-1885 | P K & A J | ||||
| Craig | Harrison | 5-17-1875 | 10-10-1875 | P K & A J | ||||
| CRAIG | Price K | 8-27-1842 | 5-22-1901 | Amelia Jane Graves - 10/15/1870 | Wesley & Sarah A Jones Craig | Cpl Co H 138th Ill Inf | ||
| Craig | Priscilla | 3-6-1879 | 3-14-1883 | P K & A J | ||||
| Craig | Russell | 5-14-1881 | 9-24-1895 | P K & Jane | obit | |||
| Dasher | Rebecca | 9-28-1836 | 3-26-1870 | |||||
| Davidson | Rachel Ann | 11-21-1832 | 10-3-1853 | J C | ||||
| DeVoe | Adah | 1894 | 1973 | |||||
| Dodridge | Rebeca Ann (Nixon) | 9-28-1836 | 3-26-1870 | Loyal M | John & Hannah Pennock Nixon | |||
| Dorn | Florence | abt 1873 | 1-23-1903 | obit | ||||
| Ertle | Pricilla Ann (Allen) | 11-4-1844 | 2-2-1902 | James W - 2/11/1863 | obit | |||
| Faris | H W - son | 3-10-1878 | 8-21-1878 | J W & M W | ||||
| Faris | J W | 2-16-1843 | 6-6-1905 | |||||
| Faris | M E - daughter | 1-16-1864 | 9-23-1864 | J W & M W | ||||
| Faris | Melissa W | 5-4-1837 | 3-5-1899 | J W | ||||
| Fenton | Anna Eliza (Miller) | 1-11-1855 | 10-10-1884 | George | ||||
| Graves | Evy M | 4-4-1856 | 6-17-1863 | L Y & Mary | ||||
| Graves | Layton Y | 1-15-1815 | 11-10-1894 | |||||
| Graves | Mariah A | 5-26-1854 | 6-23-1868 | L Y & Mary | ||||
| Graves | Mary | 2-12-1821 | 1-1-1886 | L Y | ||||
| Graves | Thomas L | 10-16-1857 | 6-23-1863 | L Y & Mary | ||||
| Harris | Samuel | 1836 | 1845 | |||||
| Hevelin | George E | 2-12-1876 | 12-28-1895 | George & Ann Eliza | ||||
| Holman | Alma | 1887 | 1887 | |||||
| Hupes | Allie | 8-23-1864 | ||||||
| James | Jesse | 1841 | William & Mary | Civil War Co E 89th Ind Inf | ||||
| Kirby | Ellen | 1859 | 1889 | Jo | ||||
| Kunce | Byron J | 10-22-1893 | 10-13-1895 | George & Sylvania Coulson Kunce | obit | |||
| Lacey | Anna Eliza (Pennock) | 1824 | 1898 | John H | Joshua & Mary Knapp Pennock | |||
| Lacey | Earl H | 2-9-1888 | 10-28-1893 | F H & Ann | ||||
| Lacey | Elizabeth A | 6-1-1875 | 6-28-1875 | F H & S C | ||||
| Lacey | Fernando H | 1846 | 1908 | Nancy A | ||||
| Lacey | Nancy A | 1848 | 1918 | Fernando H | ||||
| Lacey | Sarah C | 6-10-1875 | F H | |||||
| Lacey-Pierson | Anna Eliza | 1824 | 1898 | William H Pierson | ||||
| Lacy | Mary J | 1866 | 1884 | |||||
| Longstreth | Saloma (Baker) | 7-19-1820 | 2-22-1857 | Samuel | ||||
| Longstreth | Samuel | 8-19-1820 | 3-22-1859 | |||||
| Lutes | B A[nn] (Manning) | 4-23-1833 | 7-22-1881 | T M C - 7/4/1858 | Paul & Barbara A Manning | |||
| Lutes | Elijah M | 10-1-1862 | 10-12-1864 | T M C & B A | ||||
| Lutes | Hannibal H | 1-10-1861 | 7-25-1862 | T M C & B A | ||||
| Lutes | Sarah J (Nixon) | 10-11-1835 | 4-21-1858 | T M C - 9/13/1855 | John & Hannah Pennock Nixon | |||
| LUTES | T[homas] M C | 5-2-1833 | 6-27-1896 | Sarah J Nixon - 1855; Ann Manning - 1858; Matilda J Newland - 1882 | John & Mary Parker Lutes | Cpl Co F 140th IN Inf | obit | |
| McCurdy | Sarah (Hamrick) | 9-30-1804 | 8-7-1894 | John | obit | |||
| McVey | Angeline | 1827 | 1905 | |||||
| McVey | Milton | 1817 | 1881 | |||||
| Medsker | Abraham | 6-9-1792 | 10-12-1865 | Isabella Wright; Elizabeth Sheppard | Jacob & Margaret Hamilton Metsker | |||
| Medsker | Elizabeth (Sheppard) | 5-18-1785 | 7-29-1855 | Eli Bereman; Abraham Medsker | Joel & Hannah Jenkins Sheppard | |||
| Medsker | Isabella (Wright) | 2-22-1810 | 5-9-1888 | Abraham - 10/21/1855 | John & Ann Cook Wright | |||
| Meranda | James P | 5-27-1847 | 3-18-1877 | Co H 124th Ind Inf | ||||
| Miller | Emanuel Trone | 4-19-1828 | 12-18-1915 | s/s Jane | John F | |||
| Miller | H Jane | 1861 | 1934 | s/s Lee N | ||||
| Miller | Lee N | 1857 | 1930 | s/s H Jane | ||||
| Miller | [Sarah] Jane (Myers) | 1-13-1834 | 7-9-1916 | Emanuel T | Benjamin P & Rachel Ehrhart Myers | |||
| Miller | William David | 12-4-1861 | 1-12-1886 | E T & Jane | ||||
| Millikan | Samuel Harris | 1836 | 1845 | Jesse & L A | ||||
| Mills | Ardon | 1857 | 1922 | s/s Ella B | ||||
| Mills | Benjamin F | 4-21-1869 | 2-1-1883 | |||||
| Mills | Benjamin F | 12-9-1818 | 1-2-1894 | Louisa A | ||||
| Mills | Earnest G | 1884 | 1884 | s/s Freddie A | ||||
| Mills | Ella B | 1859 | 1926 | s/s Ardon | ||||
| Mills | Elmer | 7-30-1882 | 1-23-1885 | B F & C J | ||||
| Mills | Freddie A | 1892 | 1897 | s/s Earnest G | ||||
| Mills | Louisa Ann (Hodge) | 8-11-1808 | 7-26-1887 | Benjamin F | ||||
| Mills | Mary Ann (Campbell) | 1-3-1797 | 11-3-1874 | James | ||||
| Mitchell | James | 11-5-1859 | Hanson | |||||
| Moon | Lindley H | 1841 | 1934 | s/s Susan J | ||||
| Moon | Susan Jane | 1865 | 1931 | s/s Lindley H | ||||
| Moon | Susannah | 1853 | 7-5-1891 | L H | ||||
| Mundhenk | Infants | 1-19-1890 | 1-19-1890 | Twins of Eugene E & Ella M Trehearne Mundhenk | ||||
| Munsey | Rebecca | 1820 | 1896 | |||||
| Munsey | Samuel E | 1843 | 1924 | |||||
| Munsey | Skidmore | 1802 | 1887 | |||||
| Myers | Clifford | no dates | ||||||
| Myers | Otto | no dates | ||||||
| Nixon | Eliza | 6-8-1851 | 8-27-1854 | John & Hannah Pennock Nixon | ||||
| Nixon | Emanuel | 12-31-1844 | 7-30-1934 | Malinda C | John & Hannah Pennock Nixon | |||
| Nixon | Emretta (Ullom) | 1841 | 1933 | William | ||||
| Nixon | Grace | 7-21-1902* | 5-22-1903 | Millard & Florence | obit | |||
| Nixon | Hannah (Pennock) | 3-7-1814 | 10-1-1874 | John | ||||
| Nixon | John | 5-25-1811 | 6-28-1887 | Hannah P | obit | |||
| Nixon | Malinda C | 4-23-1849 | 6-8-1909 | Emanuel | BHFHR | |||
| Nixon | Norma J | 1932 | 3/23/2004 | Richard D - 9/10/1950 | death notice | |||
| Nixon | Richard D | 1932 | Norma J | |||||
| Nixon | William | 10-6-1840 | 5-6-1895 | Emretta Ullom | John & Hannah Pennock Nixon | |||
| Nixon | William W | 1880 | 1919 | |||||
| Parker | Allen W | 1835 | 1909 | Elizabeth | Co M 3rd IN Cav | |||
| Parker | Elizabeth | 1839 | 1882 | Allen W | ||||
| Peirson | Eliza M | 1854 | 1930 | |||||
| Peirson | Elmer C | 8-9-1874 | 7-6-1875 | J M & M J | ||||
| Peirson | Fannie Aurelia | 1895 | 1918 | |||||
| Peirson | Infant | 8-10-1874 | 8-12-1874 | J M & M J | ||||
| Peirson | John Elza | 1887 | 1920 | |||||
| Peirson | John M | 1850 | 1901 | |||||
| Peirson | Martha J | 8-24-1849 | 2-12-1875 | J M | ||||
| Peterson | Samuel | 12-30-1822 | 5-31-1855 | |||||
| Pierson | William | 5-3-1856 | 6-20-1863 | William H & Anne | ||||
| Pierson | William Henry | 1823 | 1899 | s/s Ann Eliza | ||||
| Powers | John N | 8-1-1791 | 5-2-1872 | |||||
| Powers | Winifred (Boxwell) | 5-15-1810 | 4-25-1881 | John N | ||||
| PYLE | Cheyne | 12-23-1826 | 1900 | Matilda A Steed - 2/16/1851 | George P & Ann Smith Pyle | bio: Cheney | ||
| Pyle | Elias H | 1830 | 9-14-1855 | |||||
| Pyle | I | 10-1-1857 | 6-30-1874 | |||||
| Pyle | Matilda A (Steed) | 10-1-1827 | 1917 | Cheyne | John & Frances Steed | |||
| Rhoades | Daisy | no dates | s/s Edith A "Mother" | |||||
| Rhoades | Dora | no dates | s/s Edith A "Mother" | |||||
| Rhoades | Edith A | 1863 | 1922 | |||||
| Sanders | Infant | J H & R | ||||||
| Sanders | Infant | J H & R | ||||||
| Sanders | Jacob H | 4-30-1811 | 8-10-1863 | |||||
| Sanders | Jane | 12-11-1830 | 5-3-1843 | Jacob & E | ||||
| Sanders | Ruth (Pennock) | 11-6-1814 | 4-24-1854 | |||||
| Schlosser | Adam | 1-5-1858 | 6-22-1939 | |||||
| Schlosser | Arvol C | 1893 | 10-22-1900 | M/M Adam Schlosser | obit: Orval | obit | ||
| Schlosser | Ida Alice (Sanders) | 3-9-1868 | 1-4-1900 | Adam - 9/30/1886 | M/M William Sanders | obit | ||
| Seward | Wilma Maurine (Bell) | 11-17-1907 | 4-22-1942 | William | Hasty T & Mollie Benedict Bell | |||
| Shepherd | Abigail | 1-9-1823 | 1-13-1884 | T S | ||||
| Shepherd | Alfred F P | 4-15-1846 | 8-1-1865 | Co F 140th Reg Ind Inf | ||||
| Shepherd | Almaretta | 2-25-1850 | 7-24-1854 | Thomas & Abigail | ||||
| Shepherd | McGlellen E | 8-23-1862 | 3-25-1863 | G W & L | ||||
| Shepherd | Thomas S, Dr | 5-27-1815 | 10-29-1895 | obit | ||||
| Silvers | James Monroe | 1839 | 2-23-1902 | Malenda E Foust | Teter M & Edith McCollister Silvers | obit | ||
| Silvers | Malenda E (Foust) | 1840 | 1922 | |||||
| Silvers | Russell Theodore | 9-16-1905 | 4-22-1906* | M/M J S | obit | |||
| Spealman | Ara Joel | 5-12-1943 | Cpl 319 Aux RMT Depot QMC | |||||
| Spealman | Clyde L | 4-4-1890 | 6-17-1952 | WW I Pvt 67th Inf 9th Div | ||||
| Spealman | Daniel L | 1860 | 1-20-1941 | Mary Emma Stamper | ||||
| Steed | Chester E | 8-21-1869 | 7-8-1875 | W W & E J | ||||
| Steed | Eliza Jane (Heston) | 9-22-1833 | 9-7-1904 | s/s William W | ||||
| Steed | Esther | 1-11-1883 | 9-14-1884 | Elias H & Sarah J | ||||
| Steed | Foster M | 8-12-1887 | 9-21-1896 | H H & P J | ||||
| Steed | Francis (Aker) | 6-13-1794 | 12-13-1876 | John | ||||
| Steed | Guy | 12-5-1893 | 9-17-1896 | H H & P J | ||||
| Steed | Infant daughter | 9-7-1884 | 9-7-1884 | Lewis N & Flora B | ||||
| Steed | John | 5-30-1791 | 8-15-1872 | |||||
| Steed | Palmer | 8-19-1885 | 7-8-1896 | E H & S J | ||||
| Steed | William Wesley | 3-9-1825 | 12-28-1899 | Eliza Jane Heston | John & Frances Aker Steed | |||
| Stratton | Amanda Lucinda (Nixon) | 1857 | 1927 | John & Hannah Pennock Nixon | ||||
| Stratton | Cyrus Martin | 12-24-1847 | 2-19-1921 | Lusetta | ||||
| Stratton | Lusetta (Nixon) | 1849 | 1928 | Cyrus M | ||||
| Trehearne | Ervine | 5/29/1891 | 1892 | Levin H & Margaret E Gibbs Trehearne | ||||
| Trehearne | Joseph | 3/25/1887 | 1888 | Levin H & Margaret E Gibbs Trehearne | ||||
| Trehearne | Lydia (Ward) | 1815 | 1899 | Samuel W | ||||
| Trehearne | Samuel Wonnell | 4-27-1815 | 10-18-1894 | Sarah C Hazzard; Lydia Ward | James S & Sally Wonnell Trehearne | |||
| Trehearne | Sarah Caroline (Hazzard) | 10-28-1820 | 7-6-1857 | Cord & Mary P Ranklin Hazzard | ||||
| Trehearne | Sarah F (Powers) | 6-16-1846 | 4-19-1875 | Levin H | John N & Winifred Powers | |||
| Trehearne | Stacy Ranklin | 4-30-1857 | 1-1-1858 | Samuel W & Sarah C | ||||
| Turner | Laura E | 12-27-1870 | 12-30-1870 | W H & S M | ||||
| Turner | Sarah C | 2-14-1872 | 10-2-1872 | W H & S M | ||||
| Turner | Susanna M | 1840 | 1921 | William H | ||||
| Turner | William Henry | 1840 | 1908 | Susanna M | Co E 81st OH Inf | |||
| Ullom | Elios | 10-2-1850 | 10-18-1865 | J & S | ||||
| Ullom | Jacob | 3-19-1819 | 8-29-1881 | Susanah Ray | ||||
| Ullom | Stephen | 1865 | J & S | Civil War Co A 138 IN Inf | ||||
| Ullom | Susanah (Ray) | 4-2-1819 | 7-13-1851 | Jacob | ||||
| Unknown | John W | 1-19-1863 | 9-11-1863 | J C & L C | ||||
| Vandeusen | Mary J | 1862 | 6-19-1863 | J M & L | ||||
| VanSkyock | Benjamin Franklin | 1850 | 1926 | s/s Matilda | ||||
| VanSkyock | Elias | 1848 | 1934 | s/s Mary A | ||||
| VanSkyock | Mary Ann | 1848 | 1904 | s/s Elias | ||||
| VanSkyock | Matilda (Nixon) | 5-5-1849 | 7-6-1906 | Benjamin F | John & Hannah Pennock Nixon | |||
| VanSkyock | Unknown | 4-16-1909 | Frank | BHFHR | ||||
| Watson | Anne | 1780 | 10-9-1853 | Joseph | ||||
| Watson | Joseph | 7-3-1775 | 10-2-1855 | Anne | ||||
| Williams | Edward E | 1947 | 1947 | |||||
| Wright | Martha | William | ||||||
| Wright | William | 2-4-1826 | 8-25-1866 | Civil War Co D 23rd IN Inf | ||||
