| According to old records there are supposedly about 275 graves in this cemetery, but only the ones listed below have markers. A map exists, made by the late Arthur J. Beckman when he was in Brookville High School under the history tutelage of the late Virgil E. Davis. The map is in rough form, and is intended to be updated (but never was). Many, if not most, of the graves are marked in German lettering but in most instances have been translated into English. The open spaces also have graves, not marked. | |||
| Name | Birth Date/Age | Death Date | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rachel Elleman | Jun 25, 1824 | Mar 22, 1916 | |
| Katherine Hilkene | May 27, 1838 | Mar 27, 1916 | |
| Henry Hilkene | Oct 11, 1815 | Oct 19, 1916 | |
| John C. Minneman | Dec 4, 1840 | Oct 19, 1890 | |
| William F. Schocke | 1867 | 1889 | |
| Mary Grimme | 1842 | 1889 | |
| William Quante | 1836 | 1889 | |
| Louisa Mergenthal | 1889 | ||
| M. Catharine Miller | 1803 | 1889 | |
| Margaret Mergenthal | 187? | ||
| John Quante | 1804 | 1889 | |
| Sophia Quante | 1811 | 1887 | |
| William M. Mergenthal | 1869 | 1886 | |
| Mary Sander | 1886 | ||
| Frederick Ellerman |  Co F, 146th Ind Inf Civil War |
||
| John Sauter | 1810 | 1885 | |
| Martin Bossert | 1820 | 1905 | |
| Philobena Bossert | 1826 | 1885 | |
| John Finck | 1884 | ||
| William Bocher (Baker) | 1854 | 1884 | |
| Valentine Rief | 1830 | 1883 | |
| Benjamin F.H.Charles Bruns | Mar 8, 1877 | Sep 28, 1882 | |
| Maggie S. Quante | Aug 5, 1886 | Aug 5, 1886 | |
| Henry Hilkene | Sep 7, 1886 | Sep 9, 1886 | |
| Meini Grimme | Apr 2, 1878 | Mar 28, 1888 | |
| Louisa S. Hilkene | Mar 23, 1863 | Aug 23, 1891 | |
| Sophia E. Minneman | May 4, 1806 | Apr 25, 1883 | |
| John H. Minneman | Dec 31, 1797 | Apr 25, 1880 | |
| Anna Marie Franzman | 1812 | 1885 | born in Hesse-Darmstadt |
| John Franzman | 1808 | 1879 | born in Hesse-Darmstadt |
| Wilhelmina D.F. Mahle | |||
| George Miller | 1878 | ||
| Henry C. Mahle | 1794 | 1879 | |
| Jacob Morelock | 1878 | ||
| Sophia Bruns | 1878 | ||
| Elizabeth Sauter | 1848 | 1877 | |
| John F. Klemme | Feb 2, 1792 | Aug 24, 1881 | |
| Georgie H. Bruns | Feb 7, 1875 | Mar 24, 1876 | |
| Rosa G. Bruns | Mar 15, 1861 | Mar 9, 1876 | |
| Henry Bohlander | Mar 4, 1809 | Jun 22, 1881 | |
| Margaret Bohlander | Jan 23, 1804 | Jan 28, 1884 | |
| Mary Dehr | 1812 | Jan 23, 1869 | |
| Mary Charlotte Klemme | May 5, 1798 | Mar 12, 1870 | born in Hesse |
| Anna M. Wolber | Mar 28, 1854 | Apr 6, 1870 | |
| L.C.Precht | Mar 20, 1855 | May 8, 1870 | |
| Christina Graf | Jul 4, 1817 | Nov 19, 1875 | |
| Frederick Reidenbach | Oct 24, 1847 | Jul 1, 1871 | |
| Eva Luntz | Mar 12, 1808 | Sep 26, 1875 | |
| Francis J. Grimme | May 4, 1805 | Aug 28, 1871 | |
| Anna M. Bulier | Jun 4, 1846 | Feb 27, 1873 | |
| Jacob Mahle | Jul 18, 1874 | Age 17 years | |
| John W.F. Grimme | Oct 21, 1803 | Feb 26, 1875 | |
| Katharine Gross | |||
| John G. Graf | Sep 29, 1811 | Apr 13, 1876 | |
| Michael Mergenthal | Jun 28, 1876 | Age 72 years | |
| George J.L.Reiboldt | Jun 24, 1864 | Nov 26, 1865 | |
| John Bulier | 1870 | 1872 | |
| Infant son of J & A Bulier | 1871 | 1871 | |
| Louisa M. Bulier | 1879 | 1879 | |
| Elizabeth M. Wolber | May 11, 1873 | Apr 8, 1875 | |
| Herman Bocher (Baker) | Sep 7, 1829 | Nov 4, 1880 | |
| John F. Bocher (Baker) | Jun 16, 1871 | Age 10 years
|
|
| Amalia Schreiber | Dec 28, 1839 | Apr 5, 1877 | |
| Johanna Bocher (Baker) | 1837 | 1877 | |
| Mary Rief | 1876 | Age 45 years | |
| Katharina Rief | 187? | Age 19 | |
| Andreas Schmitt | 1850 | 1860 | |
| Peter Bossert | Apr 22, 1823 | Jun 9, 1862 | |
| John Mergenthal | Feb 9, 1840 | Aug 23, 1863 | |
| Menia Bruns | Aug 26, 1863 | Age 39 Years | |
| Caroline Reidenbach | Mar 3, 1864 | Age 12 | |
| Andrew Bossert | Jun 23, 1785 | Sep 5, 1864 | |
| John H. Ellerman | May 2, 1800 | Oct 16, 1864 | |
| Dietrich L. Quante | Nov 22, 1842 | Oct 9, 1865 | |
| J.C.Frederick Grimme | Jan 18, 1802 | Sep 10, 1866 | |
| John Herman Bruns | Januray 21, 1796 | Jan 15, 1864 | |
| John Poppe | Mar 25, 1860 | Feb 21, 1861 | |
| Henrietta Poppe | Sep 25, 1858 | Mar 8, 1861 | |
| Malina Mahle | Dec 28, 1860 | 1861 | |
| John Adam Quante | 1863 | 1864 | |
| Henry F. Ellerman | Jan 30, 1864 | May 15, 1864 | |
| Carl Peterson | 1815 | 1876 | |
| Henry Dr. (Dietrich) Beckman | 1790 | 1853 | Born in Hannover |
| Katharine Bohlander | 1840 | 1853 | |
| John Gross | |||
| Jacob Meddel | 1788 | 1857 | |
| John J. Reiboldt | 1819 | 1857 | |
| William G. Miller | 1867 | 1877 | |
| C.Lissie Miller | 1875 | 1877 | |
| Anna Mary Bossert | 1797 | 1845 | Born in Hessen |
| Jacob Reidenbach | 1848 | 1851 |
|
