In 1986, Helen Moore prepared a report on the three Peppertown cemeteries: the Old Public Cemetery, the German Lutheran Church Cemetery and the New Cemetery. Helen was a member of the Indiana State Board of the Indiana German Heritage Society. Her relatives came directly to Peppertown from Germany in 1849, and she has relatives buried in the Old Public Cemetery. These listings are based on her report and were originally posted on Larry Christensen's website on AOL. Because AOL closed their home pages service in 2008, we have reproduced as much of the listings as we could reconstruct. Contains only graves having headstones with names.
| West Half of Cemetery | |||
| Name | Birth Date/Age | Death Date | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| TEUFEL, Adam | 1887 | 1888 | Infant |
| HORSTMAN, William H | 1868 | 18 Mar 1935 | Died at About Age 66 Heart Attack |
| HORSTMAN, Christina [CHRISTIAN] | 28 Apr 1835 | 19 MAR 1913 | |
| HOSE, ____ | 1858 | 1922 | "Mother" |
| HOSE, Henry | 1847 | 1928 | |
| HOSE, Frank | 1881 | 1926 | |
| SCHUNEMAN, Manda | |||
| WOLF, Earl Dewey | 9 Apr 1897 | 14 Nov 1925 | s/o John Wolf & Lucinda |
| WOLF, Lucinda or Luzenda | 17 Apr 1855 | 18 Sep 1920 | w/o John b Jun 1851 |
| WOLF, Ray "Buddy" | May 1892 | s/o John Wolf & Lucinda | |
| METCALF, Harold | 25 Mar 1947 | 12 Mar 1968 |  Battery C, 8th Bn, 4th Arty Viet Nam |
| STOVER, Carl | |||
| SCHLIGEL, Maggie | 1869 | 1898 | |
| WOLF, Henry | |||
| KOEHLER, Louis | 20 Jun 1881? | 19 Sep 1953 | s/o Vitus Koehler? & Mary Elizabeth Schirer? |
| KOEHLER, John | 24 Jun 1874? | s/o Vitus Koehler? & Mary Elizabeth Schirer? | |
| STIRN, Louis Friedrich | 1857 | 6 Nov 1932 | h/o Margaret B Teufel |
| STIRN, Margaret Teufel | 1863 | 5 Nov 1951 | d/o John & Elizabeth Teufel |
| STIRN, Lula A (Emilia) | 30 Jul 1899 | ||
| STIRN, Wilhelmine Brack | 1885 | 1961 | |
| UNKNOWN HOBO | |||
| STIRN, Louis F | 1879 | 3 Mar 1946 | s/o Henry Stirn & Martha Elizabeth Roemer? |
| STIRN, Anna M | 7 Feb 1884 | 8 Mar 1966 | d/o Henry Stirn & Martha Elizabeth Roemer? |
| STIRN, Carl F | 30 Jun 1888 | 13 Mar 1986 | |
| STIRN, Katherine E Luck | 12 Jan 1900 | 29 Sep 1931 | |
| BECHT, Jesse | |||
| WOLF, Charles | Might be the Charles Wolf who m Elizabeth Hose | ||
| WOLF, ____ | 13 Oct 1813 | 1884 | |
| WOLF, Mary Elizabeth | 1870 | 30 Sep 1980 | |
| WOLF, George Karl | 10 Nov 1807 | ||
| WOLF, Eugene Charles | 9 Sep 1829 | 28 Sep 1829 | |
| WOLF, Roy | 21 Apr 1918 | 21 Apr 1918 | |
| WOLF, Karl | 11 Mar 1845 | 22 Aug 1880 | Veteran |
| WOLF, Elizabeth | 1844 | 1920 or 1940 | |
| STIRN, Andrew | |||
| WAMBACH, Anna Catharina | 18 Oct 1817 | 4 Aug 1898 | w/o John Wambach b abt 1822 |
| WAMBACH, Johann | 1 Dec 1831 | 12 Dec 1907 | |
| STIRN, Martha Elizabeth | 28 Feb 1852 | 11 Dec 1927 | |
| REIFEL, Michael | 29 Dec 1832 | 18 Jun 1921 | h/o Wilhelmina Doebling, s/o Henry Reifel & Margaret Deitrich |
| REIFEL, Wilhelmina Doebling | 5 Mar 1836 | 20 Aug 1897 | w/o Michael Reifel, d/o Casper & Mary Doebling |
| ROEMER, Anna Martha | 10 Apr 1816 | 24 Feb 1888 | w/o Heinrich Roemer |
| ROEMER, Heinrich | 26 Aug 1818 | 13 Aug 1891 | h/o Anna Martha |
| ROEMER, Justus | 14 Jul 1852 | 10 Jun 1895 | h/o Margaret Reifel? |
| ROEMER, Margaret Reifel? | 18 Jan 1859 | 19 Jul 1935 | w/o Justus |
| REIFEL, Anna G | 12 Jan 1847 | 1 Feb 1889 | Maybe 1st w/o Christian Ellerman |
| REIFEL, Theobald | 5 Mar 1842 | 1 Mar 1876 | |
| ELLERMAN, Anna | Oct 1865 | ||
| HANNEBAUM, Catherine Margaret Wulber | 28 Sep 1842 | 7 Aug 1929 | w/o Henry Hannebaum, d/o Henry & Mary Wulber |
| HANNEBAUM, Johann Heinrich "Henry" | 5 May 1827 | 11 Aug 1875 | h/o Catherine Wulber, s/o J Friedrich & Catherine Bredenwischer Hannebaum |
| REIFEL, Conrad | 22 Feb 1840 | 13 Aug 1917 | h/o Louisa Koerner, s/o George Heinrich & Margaret |
| REIFEL, Catherine Christina | 7 Jul 1851 | 23 Feb 1893 | d/o Heinrich & Margaret Reifel |
| REIFEL, George Heinrich | 14 Apr 1805 | 4 Nov 1887 | h/o Margaret |
| REIFEL, George Philip | 1855 | 16 Nov 1933 | h/o Catherine L Horstman, s/o Philip |
| PEPPER, Bobby | 1934 | 1934 | s/o William Frederick & Kate Reifel Pepper |
| STIRN, Wilhelm Andrew Sr | 5 May 1874 | 17 May 1968 | h/o Augusta K Pepper, s/o Henry & Martha Elizabeth Roemer Stirn |
| STIRN, Augusta K "Gussie" Pepper | 7 May 1882 | 5 Apr 1965 | d/o Louis R & Caroline Heineman Pepper |
| PEPPER, Will | Abt 1865 | s/o August & Eliza Hannebaum Pepper | |
| REIFEL, Catherine L Horstman | 17 Apr 1856 | 9 Apr 1935 | w/o George Philip Reifel |
| KIRSCHBAUM, Magdalena "Lena" | 5 Jan 1824 | 24 May 1895 | w/o John Michael Kirschbaum? |
| KIRSCHBAUM, John Michael | 1812 | 18 Sep 1876 | |
| KIRSCHBAUM, Maria | |||
| KIRSCHBAUM, Johann | |||
| KIRSCHBAUM, ____ | 17 Apr 1895 | ||
| KIRSCHBAUM, Carolina | 8 Aug 1901 | ||
| KIRSCHBAUM, George Frank Walter | 4 Aug 1899 | ||
| KIRSCHBAUM, Frank | 19 Jun 1899 | 28 May 1904 | |
| KOERNER, Matheus | |||
| KOERNER, Dora M | 24 Sep 1826 | 28 Sep 1881 | |
| KOERNER, Charlotte Pepper | 12 Jan 1800 | 3 Jan 1866 | |
| KOERNER, Louisa | 12 Aug 1825 | 17 Aug 1871 | 2nd w/o John C Koerner |
| KOERNER, Gustav A | 19 Mar 1855 | 15 Feb 1860 | s/o John C & Eliza Koerner |
| KOERNER, Henry Albert | 13 Mar 1857 | 12 Jan 1860 | s/o John C & Eliza Koerner |
| KOERNER, John C | 14 Feb 1812 | 17 Jul 1892 | |
| MOHR, Conrad | 4 Aug 1842 | 26 Mar 1914 | h/o Elizabeth Boltz, s/o Jacob L & Eva Catherine Reifel Mohr |
| MOHR, Elizabeth | 21 Dec 1850 | 22 Oct 1925 | w/o Conrad Mohr, d/o Georg M & Eva Postel Boltz |
| ALLEY, William Arrington | 1932 | 25 Feb 1907 or 1917 | h/o Elizabeth, s/o David Alley & Rebecca Jones |
| ALLEY, Elizabeth | 1933 | 19__ | w/o William A Alley |
| ALLEY, Elizabeth Christine | 6 Jun 1869 | 17 Jul 1912 | "Daughter" |
| ALLEY, Hester | 1950 | ||
| ALLEY, Florence | |||
| WOLF, Herbert | |||
| JOHNSON, Roy | |||
| JOHNSON, Selvia | |||
| East Half of Cemetery | |||
| Name | Birth Date/Age | Death Date | Notes |
| HANNEBAUM, Virgil R | 24 Mar 1911 | h/o Dorotha Zimmerman, s/o Charles O & Clara Reifel Hannebaum | |
| HANNEBAUM, Dorotha A Zimmerman | 9 Oct 1914 | 20 Nov 1966 | w/o Virgil Hannebaum |
| HANNEBAUM, Rita Catherine "Retha" | 11 Mar 1944 | 13 May 1944 | d/o Virgil & Dorotha Zimmerman Hannebaum |
| REIFEL, Jacob W | 5 Aug 1849 | 4 Jan 1934 | h/o Mary M Kirschbaum, s/o George H & Margaret Reifel |
| REIFEL, Mary M Kirschbaum | 31 Aug 1952 | 11 Jan 1923 | w/o Jacob W Reifel |
| BECKER, Peter | 1852 | 1915 | |
| BECKER, Minnie | 1856 | 1928 | |
| BECKER, Edmund | 1888 | 1913 | |
| BECKER, Charles Lewis | |||
| BRINKMAN, John | 11 Nov 1861 | 25 Jan 1901 | h/o Paulina Pepper, s/o Joseph H & Catherine Hannebaum Brinkman |
| GLOSHEN, Birdie Virginia | 1 Sep 1879 | 7 Dec 1945 | d/o Frederick & Essie Pepper Gloshen |
| SCHERER, Max | 12 Aug 1879 | 27 Feb 1957 | Co E, 2nd Regt NJ Inf Spanish-American War, h/o Paulina Pepper Brinkman |
| SCHERER, Paulina Louise Pepper Brinkman | 1857 | 10 Jul 1941 | d/o August & Eliza Hannebaum Pepper; w/o Max Scherer; 1st husband John Brinkman |
| GLOSHEN, Flora Augusta | 8 Oct 1878 | 18 Nov 1885 | d/o Frederick & Essie Gloshen |
| GLOSHEN, Frederick | 7 Jul 1853 | 21 Sep 1880 | h/o Essie Pepper, s/o Nicholas & Gincy Jones Gloshen |
| PEPPER, August | 25 Nov 1821 | 8 Jun 1889 | h/o Eliza Hannebaum. Settled at this site in 1851; Peppertown named for August |
| GLOSHEN, Essie Pepper | 4 Dec 1861 | 7 Mar 1890 | s/o Frederick Gloshen, d/o August & Eliza Hannebaum Pepper |
| SMITH, Adam | Dec 1809 | 6 Apr 1885 | h/o Margaret |
| SMITH, Margaret | 25 Oct 1850 | 12 Feb 1914 | d/o Adam & Margaret Smith |
| BRAUN, Frank | 1854 | 1886 | |
| BRAUN, J Frank | 13 Nov 1876 | 1 May 1909 | |
| STIERLE, Jacob | 12 Jun 1827 | 3 Aug 1913 | h/o Walburga |
| STIERLE, Walburga | 21 Jun 1833 | 26 Oct 1902 | w/o Jacob |
| BECKY, Anna | 26 Oct 1826 | 22 Mar 1899 | |
| BECKY, Wilhelm (Walter) | 3 Dec 1816 | 23 Dec 1902 | |
| BECKY, William | 29 Dec 1863 | 31 Mar 1887 | |
| BECKY, William M | 2 Mar 1860 | 25 Dec 1904 | |
| PALMER, Raymond J | 20 Oct 1894 | 19 Mar 1896 | |
| STIRN, George Michael | 15 Apr 1806 | 11 Mar 1883 | |
| STIRN, Henry | 13 Feb 1917 | ||
| BRACK, Katharina | 15 Sep 1827 | 26 Mar 1889 | |
| BRACK, Ludwig | 18 Oct 1827 | 24 Nov 1879 | |
| LANDSETEL, Catharina Brack | 12 Aug 1864 | 14 Jan 1892 | w/o Henry Landsetel, sister of Margaret Sophia |
| LANDSETEL, Margaret Sophia | 1867 | 1939 | 2nd w/o Henry Landsetel, sister of Catharina |
| SCHUNEMAN, Anna K | 1877 | 8 Dec 1950 | w/o Louis P, d/o Henry & Martha Elizabeth Roemer Stirn |
| SCHUNEMAN, Martha F | 1905 | 10 Feb 1910 | |
| HANNEBAUM, Charles O | 12 Feb 1875 | 8 Jun 1960 | 1st wife Clara M Reifel, 2nd wife Matilda Schuneman Swartz; s/o Henry & Catherine Wulber Hannebaum |
| HANNEBAUM, Clara M | 13 Jun 1878 | 24 Mar 1915 | w/o Charles O Hannebaum, d/o W & Marie Kirschbaum Reifel |
| POWELL, Alma Marie | 2 Nov 1902 | 16 Feb 1934 | w/o Clarence Earl Powell, d/o Charles O & Clara Reifel Hannebaum |
| TEUFEL, Anna Dietzel | 17 Oct 1863 | 15 Nov 1922 | w/o Fred Teufel Sr |
| TEUFEL, Fred Sr | 6 Aug 1854 | 18 Apr 1929 | h/o Anna Dietzel, s/o John & Elizabeth Teufel |
| TEUFEL, John C | 28 Sep 1902 | 26 Jul 1906 | |
| LOESCHER, Maria | circa 1812-1813 | bet 1880 & 1900 | "Mother" |
| LOESCHER, Casper | circa 1812-1813 | bet 1880 & 1900 | "Father" |
| PROUTY, Hilda E | 1892 | 1975 | |
| MARSHALL, Anna | circa 1866 | 17 Nov 1933 | |
| WITZ, Mrs | may be Weis b 1849, w/o George Adam Weis | ||
| PROUTY, K | |||
| SCHNEIDER, Louise | 11 Apr 1871 | 30 Nov 1951 | w/o Otto Schneider m 14 Aug 1889 |
| SCHNEIDER, Otto A | 11 Apr 1856 | 9 Apr 1905 | h/o Louise Stierle |
| O'BRECHT, Geraldine | 1972 | ||
| PEPPER, Karl | 11 Nov 1847 | 29 Apr 1898 | h/o Elizabeth "Lizzie" Smith, s/o August & Eliza Hannebaum Pepper |
| PEPPER, Elizabeth "Lizzie" | 7 Jan 1849 | 11 Apr 1923 | w/o Karl Pepper, d/o Adam & Margaret Smith |
| SMITH, Mary | 8 Dec 1857 | 29 Dec 1929 | d/o Adam & Margaret Smith |
| SMITH, Sarah | 28 Jan 1862 | 17 Nov 1937 | d/o Adam & Margaret Smith |
| PEPPER, Emma M | 1882 | 11 Mar 1895 | |
| DOENCH, Hilma Mohr | 5 Sep 1898 | 10 Jul 1929 | w/o Paul Doench |
| MOHR, Cora L Pepper | 29 Nov 1877 | 2 Dec 1966 | w/o William C Mohr, d/o Karl O & Elizabeth Smith Pepper |
| MOHR, Harold | 1908 | 1908 | |
| MOHR, William C "Will" | 8 Feb 1878 | 21 Oct 1950 | h/o Cora Pepper, s/o Conrad & Elizabeth Boltz Mohr |
| MOHR, Lillie | 1904 | 1906 | Twin of Willie |
| MOHR, Willie | 1904 | 1906 | Twin of Lillie |
| PETZOLD, Helen | 8 Jan 1900 | 29 Sep 1968 | w/o William Petzold, d/o William C & Cora Pepper Mohr; grave moved to Rose Hill Cem, Butler Co, OH |
| MOHR, Paul P | 10 Oct 1909 | 28 Jul 1974 | Veteran, US Navy |
| MOHR, Walter H | |||
| PETZOLD, William B "Will" | 21 Jun 1898 | 30 Aug 1983 | h/o Helen Mohr, s/o Dr August & Pauline Karsche Petzold; grave moved to Rose Hill Cem, Butler Co, OH |
| REIFEL, Almont J | 8 Feb 1881 | 12 Aug 1964 | h/o Charlotta E Pepper, s/o Jacob W & Mary M Kirschbaum Reifel |
| REIFEL, Charlotta E Pepper | 15 Jan 1884 | 23 Dec 1965 | w/o Almont J Reifel, d/o Louis R & Caroline Heineman Pepper |
| REIFEL, Vera | 1908 | 20 Jul 1933 | d/o Almont J & Lotta Pepper Reifel |
| PEPPER, August "Big August" | 27 Mar 1892 | 19 Nov 1983 | h/o Huldah M Reifel, s/o Louis R & Caroline Heineman Pepper |
| PEPPER, Huldah M Reifel | 20 May 1894 | 30 Jul 1984 | w/o August Pepper, d/o Jacob W & Mary M Kirschbaum Reifel |
| HANNEBAUM, Henry Wilhelm | 10 Feb 1871 | 23 Dec 1943 | h/o Tillia M Pepper, s/o Henry & Catherine Wulber Hannebaum |
| HANNEBAUM, Tillia M Pepper | 30 Jul 1877 | 4 Feb 1919 | w/o Henry W Hannebaum, d/o Louis R & Caroline Heineman Pepper |
| PEPPER, Louis R | 8 Jun 1849 | 25 Apr 1915 | h/o Caroline Heineman, s/o August & Eliza Hannebaum Pepper |
| PEPPER, Caroline Heineman | Aug 1852 | 1927 | w/o Louis R Pepper, d/o J Nicholas & B Catherine Heineman |
| PEPPER, August "Little August" | 20 Oct 1874 | 10 Aug 1881 | s/o Louis & Caroline Heineman Pepper |
| PEPPER, Flora | 1890 | 1892 | d/o Louis & Caroline Heineman Pepper |
| PEPPER, Herman F | 19 Apr 1885 | 10 Aug 1886 | s/o Louis & Caroline Heineman Pepper |
| HEINEMAN, B Catharina | 1 Jun 1811 | 8 Dec 1876 | w/o J Nicholas Heineman |
| HEINEMAN, J Nicholas | 17 Nov 1792 | 3 Feb 1872 | h/o B Catherine |
| SCHLIGEL, Fredrick | 1834 | 1895 | |
| SCHLIGEL, Caroline | 1838 | 1923 | |
| MILLER, Frederick | |||
| GOEHRINGER, Nora | 23 Dec 1884 | 7 Feb 1905 | |
| GOEHRINGER, John | |||
| WHITE, Henry | 11 Jun 1877 | 12 Jun 1945 | |
| ADLER, Elizabeth | 16 Dec 1851 | 22 Mar 1909 | |
| WHITE, Estella | |||
| TEUFEL, Elizabeth | 12 Oct 1902 | "Mother" | |
| TEUFEL, George Friedrich | "Father" | ||
| QUINLAN, Child | |||
| QUINLAN, Child | |||
| QUINLAN, Leslie | |||
| BLOEMER, Louise W | 1879 | 1947 | |
| DAVIDSON, Emma H | 1875 | 1954 | |
| FISHER, Ida E | 1884 | 1961 | |
| BLOEMER, Louis | |||
| ELLERMAN, Anna Marie "Annie" Meyers | 1855 | 11 Nov 1947 | 2nd w/o Christian Ellerman |
| ELLERMAN, Christian | 10 Apr 1840 | 3 Sep 1918 | Civil War Veteran; 1st wife Anna Roemer, 2nd wife Anna Marie Meyers |
| ELLERMAN, Fred | s/o Christian & Annie Meyers Ellerman | ||
| ELLERMAN, Mary | 31 Jan 1889 | ||
| ELLERMAN, Anna | Oct 1965 | ||